How It’s Possible to Have a Perfect Payment History and Bad Credit

5 min Read

DragonImages / Getty Images/iStockphoto


If you want a good credit score, you must make payments on time. This often-repeated rule is more like an undeniable fact: A solid payment history is necessary for a good credit score.

Unfortunately, a perfect payment history alone doesn’t guarantee a perfect score. A number of different factors beyond payment history affect your credit score. Neglecting any one of them can leave you with a bad credit score. You can have bad credit even if you make all payments on time and have never been a day late with mortgage payments, credit card bills or car payments.

Factors That Affect Your Credit Score

The precise formula used to derive your FICO score — the most widely used credit score — remains unknown; however, Fair Isaac Corp., which generates FICO scores, has said five factors go into your score:

Each factor affects your credit score to a different extent. But the key to having a good credit score is to give all five factors equal attention, as opposed to concentrating your efforts in one or two areas. Listed below are the five factors that affect your credit score, and how much they impact it.

Check Your Credit Today

Related: 7 Secret Perks You Enjoy If You Have a Good Credit Score

Payment History: 35 Percent

Payment history is the most important part of a credit score. No matter how well you do with the other four factors, you cannot have a good credit score if you have a bad payment history.

Fortunately, having a good payment history is as simple as paying your bills on time. Among other things, make sure you have no prior late payments, and no history of collections in your credit history.

Late payments fall into one of four categories: 30, 60, 90 and 120-plus days late. The later the payment, the more damage it does. All of these can do damage and should be avoided.

Amount Owed: 30 Percent

The “amounts owed” category doesn’t simply refer to the amount of money you owe on credit cards. Instead, it includes what’s known as the utilization percentage — how much of your available credit has been used.

You can get a more favorable rating in this category by decreasing the amount you owe. In other words, pay down your debt and spend less money each month. Another way to lower your utilization percentage is to raise your credit limit.

Check Your Credit Today

A common misconception is that you should close any credit cards that you don’t use. Ignore this widespread piece of advice. It won’t raise your score, and instead runs the risk of lowering it.

How To: Save Yourself From Financial Ruin

Length of Credit History: 15 Percent

The length of time you have had credit accounts also impacts your score. This isn’t a measure of how old you are — it’s illegal to use such criteria when formulating your credit score. Instead, it’s a measure of how long on average you have had accounts open.

One of the most frustrating aspects of building credit is that you have to play a waiting game. You can’t take concrete steps that will immediately help increase your score. You can, however, take steps now that will help you in the long run.

The sooner you start opening accounts, the sooner you start building a credit history. Remember that there’s no point in closing old accounts, because such accounts actually lengthen your credit history.

Check Your Credit Today

New Credit: 10 Percent

New credit refers to how often you apply for new credit, and it’s a big deal due to something called inquiries. An inquiry keeps track of who pulled your credit report when you applied for new credit. Inquiries are divided into two types: hard inquiries and soft inquiries.

Hard inquiries occur when a lender examines your credit report. Such inquiries might take place when you apply for a loan, credit card or otherwise borrow money. These remain on your report for two years.

Soft inquiries occur when someone pulls your credit report for a reason other than that you applied for credit. The reissuing of a credit card might trigger a soft inquiry, for example. These remain on your report for six months.

It’s best to avoid either of these types of inquiries, as they cannot help your score. So, resist temptation and don’t open an unnecessary credit card, or apply for an unneeded loan that will put you in debt.

Related: 10 States With the Best and Worst Credit Scores

Check Your Credit Today

Types of Credit Used: 10 Percent

The final factor in your credit score is the types of accounts in your credit report. Three different types of credit accounts exist. To increase your credit score, you should have a mix of each.

The first type of credit is a revolving account, where the payment you’re charged each month depends on your balance. Credit cards are the most common type of revolving account.

The second type is an installment account. This type of account has a fixed payment you make for a fixed period of time. Loans are a good example of installment accounts.

The third type of credit is an open account. Like installment accounts, open accounts are due in full at the end of each month. However, like revolving accounts, they don’t feature a concrete amount that must be paid. Utility bills are an example of open accounts.

The Perfect Score Has Many Factors

It’s possible to a have perfect payment history, but still have relatively bad credit. Although a perfect payment history helps your credit score, it’s far from the only thing you have to worry about.

Five important factors figure into your credit score. Having just one perfect factor isn’t enough to guarantee a good credit score. However, having one terrible factor can be enough to get you a bad credit score.