20 Cities Where It’s Cheaper To Buy a Home Than Rent

Buying a home is often touted as a smarter financial move than renting. In the past, Americans seemed to bear this sentiment, as homeownership rates climbed year after year to reach a high of 69.2% in 2004, according to Census Bureau data. But the tide turned as the housing market started to collapse in 2007 and the U.S. economy fell into a recession. Over time, more and more people turned to renting. By 2016, the homeownership rate had fallen to 62.9%, and the percentage of renting households hit a 50-year high.
Things changed again, though, in 2017. The homeownership rate in the U.S. has been inching back up over the years and reached 65.5% in 2021, according to the Census Bureau. So, if you’re renting, should you join the renewed trend toward homeownership?
To help Americans determine whether they should continue renting or take the plunge into homeownership, GOBankingRates analyzed 80 Metro areas in the U.S. with the biggest housing markets, according to Zillow’s Housing Data, to see where you can save money in the long term by opting to buy rather than rent. The study estimated the typical monthly mortgage payment in each city by using the median list price, a 20% down payment and the current interest rate on a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage. The monthly mortgage payment was then compared to the median rent for a single-family residence, resulting in the expected savings from buying versus renting.
Note that GOBankingRates’ study doesn’t factor in the initial cost of a down payment on a home, which can take many years to save up for. The study only considers the monthly mortgage payment and rent. So, if you can get past the hurdle of a down payment, buying a home in these cities makes financial sense.
20. Little Rock, Arkansas
- Rent, January 2022: $1,035
- Home value, January 2022: $186,294
- 20% down payment: $37,259
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $843
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $192
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $2,304
19. Indianapolis, Indiana
- Rent, January 2022: $1,383
- Home value, January 2022: $253,300
- 20% down payment: $50,660
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $1,188
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $195
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $2,340
18. Atlanta, Georgia
- Rent, January 2022: $1,861
- Home value, January 2022: $350,758
- 20% down payment: $70,152
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $1,663
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $198
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $2,376
17. Dayton, Ohio
- Rent, January 2022: $1,157
- Home value, January 2022: $181,062
- 20% down payment: $36,212
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $956
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $201
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $2,412
16. Allentown, Pennsylvania
- Rent, January 2022: $1,687
- Home value, January 2022: $283,534
- 20% down payment: $56,707
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $1,476
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $211
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $2,532
15. Knoxville, Tennessee
- Rent, January 2022: $1,497
- Home value, January 2022: $282,038
- 20% down payment: $56,408
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $1,281
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $216
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $2,592
14. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- Rent, January 2022: $1,299
- Home value, January 2022: $205,112
- 20% down payment: $41,022
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $1,068
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $231
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $2,772
13. Baton Rouge, Louisiana
- Rent, January 2022: $1,253
- Home value, January 2022: $226,177
- 20% down payment: $45,235
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $1,004
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $249
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $2,988
12. New Orleans, Louisiana
- Rent, January 2022: $1,460
- Home value, January 2022: $259,825
- 20% down payment: $51,965
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $1,154
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $306
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $3,672
11. Birmingham, Alabama
- Rent, January 2022: $1,281
- Home value, January 2022: $225,114
- 20% down payment: $45,023
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $973
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $308
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $3,696
10. Oklahoma City
- Rent, January 2022: $1,265
- Home value, January 2022: $202,471
- 20% down payment: $40,494
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $953
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $312
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $3,744
9. El Paso, Texas
- Rent, January 2022: $1,285
- Home value, January 2022: $179,893
- 20% down payment: $35,979
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $962
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $323
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $3,876
8. Tampa
- Rent, January 2022: $1,977
- Home value, January 2022: $347,793
- 20% down payment: $69,559
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $1,646
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $331
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $3,972
7. Tulsa, Oklahoma
- Rent, January 2022: $1,272
- Home value, January 2022: $195,585
- 20% down payment: $39,117
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $921
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $351
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $4,212
6. Syracuse, New York
- Rent, January 2022: $1,298
- Home value, January 2022: $182,345
- 20% down payment: $36,469
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $930
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $368
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $4,416
5. North Port/Sarasota/Bradenton
- Rent, January 2022: $2,433
- Home value, January 2022: $434,234
- 20% down payment: $86,847
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $2,055
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $378
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $4,536
4. Greensboro, North Carolina
- Rent, January 2022: $1,389
- Home value, January 2022: $211,892
- 20% down payment: $42,378
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $989
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $400
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $4,800
3. Columbia, South Carolina
- Rent, January 2022: $1,387
- Home value, January 2022: $214,768
- 20% down payment: $42,954
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $957
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $430
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $5,160
2. Memphis, Tennessee
- Rent, January 2022: $1,473
- Home value, January 2022: $212,217
- 20% down payment: $42,443
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $964
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $509
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $6,108
1. Miami, Florida
- Rent, January 2022: $2,817
- Home value, January 2022: $467,826
- 20% down payment: $93,565
- Monthly mortgage payment after 20% down: $2,214
- Difference between rent and mortgage payment: $603
- Annual savings when you buy instead of rent: $7,236
More From GOBankingRates
- How Big Is Mitt Romney's Social Security Check?
- Housing Market 2023: 10 US Cities with Plenty of Jobs and Cheap Housing
- 3 Ways to Recession Proof Your Retirement
- 8 Financial Habits That Improve Your Daily Life
Methodology: GOBankingRates looked at the 80 Metro areas with the biggest housing markets in the US according to Zillow’s Housing Data to determine in which cities you can save long-term by opting to buy rather than rent. GOBankingRates first compiled (1) the median hme value for single family residence homes in each metro, sourced from Zillow. This allowed (2) a median monthly mortgage payment estimate to be calculated through Zillow’s Mortgage Calculator, using a 20% down payment, the Federal Reserve Economic Data website’s current 30-year fixed rate mortgage interest rate, and state annual property tax rates sourced from the Tax Foundation. This was then compared to (3) the median monthly rental price for single family residences in each city according to Zillow to find (4) the difference between a median mortgage payment and median rent in each city. Cities were then ranked according to how much the median rent exceeds the median mortgage, with #1 being the city where the most money can be saved by buying over renting. All data was compiled on and up-to-date as of March 29, 2022.
Share this article:
Related Content

In Less Than a Decade, You'll Wish You Bought a Home in These 14 Metros
September 28, 2023
6 min Read

Housing Market 2023: Credit Score Needed To Buy Home May Not Be as High as You Think -- Here's Why
September 28, 2023
6 min Read

Want To Buy a House? Dave Ramsey Says This Is How To Tell Whether You're Ready
September 28, 2023
6 min Read

Housing Market 2023: Avoid Buying a Home in These 10 Places If You Want It To Gain Value
September 28, 2023
6 min Read




I'm a Top Real Estate Agent: Here Are the 4 Most Unexpected Housing Market Trends for 2024
September 27, 2023
6 min Read


'Selling Sunset' Star Chrishell Stause Says This Is the No. 1 Thing That Leads To Homebuyer Regret
September 26, 2023
6 min Read

I'm a Real Estate Agent: Here Are the 6 Cities Where You Should Avoid Buying a Home This Summer
September 27, 2023
6 min Read

Top Offer Picks

Build A Real Estate Fortune With Arrived
Next-Gen Wealth Building: Invest in Real Estate Via Arrived.

Protect and Secure Your Wealth With A Gold IRA
Goldco is dedicated to helping clients protect their financial future with precious metals.

Get matched with a top-rated financial advisor in your area to review your retirement plan today!
Unlock Free Access to Top Financial Advisors Near You through WiserAdvisor's Matching!

Get Paid to Share Your Opinion
Get paid to answer surveys, watch videos, shop online, and more.

Unlock $1,600+ in Savings with AARP
Become a member for only $12 your first year and receive a free gift. Membership gives you access to discounts, programs, and services from numerous trusted brands.

Could This Be a Perfect Investment Strategy?
Over 750k Masterworks members are all asking themselves that very question right now after this art investing platform achieved 100% positive net returns on 14 exits.

Access Your Home Equity With No Monthly Payments Required
Get the cash you need now and repay the loan on your own terms later.

Search For People, Property Records & Unclaimed Money
Search For People, Property Records & Unclaimed Money with BeenVerified.

Build Your Credit By Paying Netflix
Grow Credit offers a free Mastercard you can use to pay your subscriptions and build your credit.

Sign Up For Our Free Newsletter!
Get advice on achieving your financial goals and stay up to date on the day's top financial stories.
By clicking the 'Subscribe Now' button, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can click on the 'unsubscribe' link in the email at anytime.
Thank you for signing up!


Sending you timely financial stories that you can bank on.
Sign up for our daily newsletter for the latest financial news and trending topics.
For our full Privacy Policy, click here.