10 American Coins That Were Once Worth Thousands and Are Now Worth Nothing

The world of numismatics–the study and collection of coins–is filled with tales of rare and valuable coins that fetch impressive sums at auction. However, as with many collectibles, market demand can be fickle. Here’s a look at ten American coins that once held great value but have significantly depreciated over time.

The “Boomtown” Silver Dollar

Produced in the early 1900s during the Silver Rush, this coin was highly sought-after due to its limited minting. As silver lost its allure, so did the coin’s value, turning it into just another piece of metal.

1970s Bicentennial Quarters

To commemorate America’s bicentennial, the U.S. minted special quarters in the mid-70s. Initially hoarded by collectors, they were so commonly saved that their value plummeted.

“Gold Rush” Tokens

In the 1800s, private mints produced tokens that could be exchanged for goods during the Gold Rush. As federal currency stabilized, these tokens’ worth dissolved.

The Liberty “No Cents” Nickel

In its first design iteration, the Liberty Nickel did not feature the word “cents,” causing some folks to gold-plate them and pass them off as $5 gold coins. The design was quickly changed, but the original version, after a brief period of popularity, dropped in demand and value.

1999 Delaware State Quarter

When the U.S. began issuing state-specific quarters, the initial runs, like Delaware’s, were hoarded. As the novelty wore off, their value declined, making them essentially face-value coins.

Make Your Money Work Better for You

The Pilgrim Commemorative Half Dollar

Minted in the 1920s to mark the 300th anniversary of the Pilgrim landing, these coins were once highly prized. With time and the introduction of other commemorative coins, their value diminished.

1964 “Peace” Silver Dollar

Originally minted in high numbers due to the demand for silver coins, as the U.S. moved away from silver coinage, their value as collectibles decreased, with most now being worth little more than their silver content.

Presidential $1 Coins

Launched in 2007, these coins featured U.S. presidents. They were minted in large quantities, but their popularity was short-lived. Today, they’re mainly found in coin jars rather than collectors’ showcases.

Confederate States of America Coins

Produced during the Civil War by the Confederacy, these coins were initially valuable due to their historical significance. As more were found and public sentiment shifted, their value on the collector’s market declined.

Farmers Bank Tokens

In the 1800s, some banks, like the Farmers Bank, issued tokens as a form of change. As these banks closed and federal currency became the standard, these tokens lost their monetary and collector value.

The coin market can be unpredictable. While some coins might seem like a good investment at one point, their value can wane with changing economic conditions, societal shifts, or simply the passage of time. As always, collect for passion and enjoyment first, and potential profit second.

Editor's note: This article was produced via automated technology and then fine-tuned and verified for accuracy by a member of GOBankingRates' editorial team.

Make Your Money Work Better for You

More From GOBankingRates


See Today's Best
Banking Offers