As hard as it might be to believe for older sets who still talk about millennials as if they’re kids, the oldest members of that generation are now in their 40s. Many millennials are putting money into 529 plans for their own children’s college educations. Gen Z, on the other hand, is just settling into the workforce. They’re in possession of the one resource that’s even more important to investing than money — time. But is either generation walking a path that will lead to a financially secure retirement? GOBankingRates asked the experts.
Young Investors Might Be Overly Fixated on Trends and Fast Gains
According to a study from IRA rollover service Capitalize, more than half of millennials and Gen Zers are investing in cryptocurrency as part of their retirement plans. But the tendency of young investors to gravitate toward risky, volatile and trendy investments isn’t limited to digital coins. Many are also overinvested in the rock star stocks at the top of the Nasdaq composite when a more vanilla ETF might be a better long-term play.
“A steady 7% return with passive index investing over the course of a few decades doesn’t have much appeal to them,” said R.J. Weiss, a CFP and founder of the personal finance site The Ways to Wealth. “What gets their attention are things like meme stocks and massive returns of the big tech stocks like Apple and Tesla. In turn, these generations are taking a lot more risk with their portfolios. While this strategy may work short term, in the long term, few will survive the ups and downs and many can be wiped out with just one bad decision.”
But They’ve Also Been Blessed With Amazing Tech and Tools
One thing is certain. If young savers don’t invest, it’s not because they lacked the technology or know-how.
“It has never been easier to get started and save for retirement,” said Charles H. Thomas III, CFP, a financial advisor and the founder of Intrepid Eagle Finance. “The cost to get started, ease of saving and good-quality options are vastly more for Gen Y and Z compared to Gen X.”
And certainly for boomers. Investing in the stock market always came with huge barriers to entry in the form of cost, access and information. Millennials and Gen Z are the only generations who came of age having never experienced any of that. A cheap index fund in a free brokerage account paid for a little at a time through partial-share investing is theirs for the taking, even on the slimmest of budgets.
“For those who choose to make it a priority over time, they should be confident about their ability to retire,” Thomas said. “For those who haven’t yet, the only obstacle is opening up their phone and taking action.”
Many Young People Unwittingly Traded College for Retirement
If a lot of millennials and Gen Zers aren’t saving enough, it’s not because of stale boomer stereotypes about how they’ve gotten too much for free. In many cases, it’s because college cost them way too much.
“Most are not saving enough, with a primary reason being student loan payments,” Weiss said. “It’s an unfortunate situation because, for a lot of people with student loan debt, they don’t have the steady income they thought they would earn with a degree. Without a steady income, it becomes much harder to save consistently over the course of their working lives.”
Steffa Mantilla, a certified financial education instructor (CFEI) and founder of the personal finance website Money Tamer, shares Weiss’ concerns about student loans and the roadblock that college debt will be for long-term financial planning.
“For those who are crippled by debt well into their 30s, they’re going to have a late start saving for retirement,” Mantilla said. “This means they’ll not get to take full advantage of compounding interest of two additional decades. Their retirement amounts will end up being a lot lower so a full retirement is unlikely. With these two generations, more people will be working, at least part-time, well into their later years.”
The Biden administration’s student debt relief plan may be able to provide relief to members of both generations, but it’s yet to be seen if they’ll invest those savings in their retirements.
Transformative and Tumultuous Times Created Savvy Survivors
The youngest savers and investors came up in the wake of the worst terrorist attack and the longest wars in history, the worst recession since the Great Depression and the deadliest health crisis in living memory.
By and large, they adjusted, adapted, kept what worked and tossed what didn’t.
“Not everyone will be short on retirement funds,” Mantilla said. “The FIRE movement (financial independence retire early) has many early 20s to late 30s people working on the goal of reaching financial independence. They’re finding ways to live off of only 20% of their paychecks while saving the rest into tax-advantaged accounts.”
The culture of job-hopping, side-hustling and self-directed investing created versatile and adaptable savers who place a premium on multiple income streams and financial independence.
“The big trend we will see is less and less reliance on others, such as an employer’s 401(k) plan or even the government with Social Security,” Weiss said. “Instead, these generations look to take saving for retirement into their own hands and with brands that have earned their trust.”
As always, same with every generation, haves and have-nots will eventually emerge.
“Ultimately, the divide of people will be vastly different,” Mantilla said. “Some will have more than enough while others will never get to have a full retirement.”
More From GOBankingRates
- 100 Best Cities to Retire on$3,000 or Less Per Month
- Here Are All the States That Don't Tax Social Security Benefits
- 3 Ways to Recession Proof Your Retirement
- 9 Best Money Moves You Should Make This Week