Here’s When You Should Skip Costco and Shop at the Dollar Store
There’s no denying the value warehouse stores such as Costco have for American consumers. After all, where else can you spend a day getting your tires changed, enjoying a cheap lunch, shopping for groceries for the month and filling your prescriptions?
And while Costco has unbeatable prices on many items, that doesn’t mean everything you buy will save you money. Bulk packaging is the trademark of warehouse stores, and do you really need — or have room to store — a dozen cans of green beans and 30 rolls of toilet paper? And unlike toilet paper, which has an infinite shelf life, some Costco items won’t last forever, and you could wind up throwing out half of what you bought. Or more. And where’s the savings in that?
That’s why it’s worth a stroll down the aisles of your local dollar store to check the prices and availability of what you need before plopping down big money for a big package. Even though Dollar Tree raised its prices from $1 to $1.25 on many items to offset increases in shipping and other costs, shopping at dollar stores can still provide consumers with the most bang for their buck on some things.
“Dollar Tree has a ton of different specialty glassware, whereas at Costco you’ll have a seriously limited selection and you’ll have to pay more,” said Julie Ramhold, consumer analyst with DealNews.com said. “For instance, a margarita glass at Dollar Tree is $1.25, which means you can buy six for around $7.50; meanwhile, if you want a set of margarita glasses at Costco, you’ll end up paying around $24 or so for six of them. Even a 12-piece plastic tumbler set at Costco is around $25, but at Dollar Tree you can snag each one for $1.25, which works out to about $15 for a whole “set.”
Spices and Seasonings
How many old jars of spices and seasonings do you have in your kitchen cabinet, and how long have you had them? Maybe so long that you moved them from your first apartment to your forever home – and maybe they’ve lost their kick by now. When recipes only call for a half-teaspoon or a pinch, it could take a very long time to use the contents.
McCormick, a well-known manufacturer of spices and seasonings, says on its website that dried seasonings, herbs and spices in jars will last about one to two years. Herbs such as oregano and seasoning blends will add flavor for one to three years, and ground spices in the jar could be good for two to four years.
That’s where your local dollar store helps. Throw out all the old ones and start fresh. Unless you’re feeding an army – literally – the Costco spices and seasonings likely will have a good portion remaining before their shelf life runs out. Dollar Tree sells a 6.52-ounce jar of garlic salt and 4.65 ounces of lemon pepper. Their McCormick counterparts at Costco? The 41.25-ounce container of garlic salt costs $5.29, while 28 ounces of lemon pepper sells for $10.49.
“If you like to mix up your styles of dinnerware, Dollar Tree is most definitely where to go. Costco has more than a few sets, but they’re going to cost you — think 16 pieces for around $40 or more,” Ramhold said. “At Dollar Tree, each piece is $1.25 each, which means you can put together your own 16-piece set for around $20. Even the 12-piece melamine sets at Costco are more expensive per piece than what you’ll pay at Dollar Tree — it’s about $2.75 per piece, whereas Dollar Tree once again will have pieces for $1.25 each.”
Whether you’re throwing a birthday party for your 5-year-old or a sophisticated cocktail party, you can turn to the dollar store for many of your tableware needs.
With little ones, you’ll inevitably have spills and messy faces, so you’ll need plenty of napkins. But as with most Costco items, napkins come in large quantities. Really large quantities. A 2,000-count package of Marathon napkins costs $12.49 – way more than you’ll need for your party. Dollar Tree sells 20-count packages of dinner napkins and 30-count beverage napkins, and they come in festive colors, unlike the white napkins at Costco. The light blue napkins – along with the matching 48-count package of plastic silverware – will fit your “Frozen”-themed party just fine.
While you’re in the party aisle, you also can pick up some inexpensive decorations and single-use plastic tablecloths to help protect your furniture. You don’t want to cry over spilled milk, do you?
“Especially if you’re using bowls for crafting purposes and not making foods, you can’t beat $1.25 for plastic bowls with handles at Dollar Tree,” Ramhold said. “A set of four melamine bowls with lids is about $20 at Costco, but different mixing bowls at Dollar Tree are only $1.25 each. You can even get two-packs of plastic bowls without handles for $1.25, which is an even better deal. And the dollar store also has stainless steel bowls in assorted sizes, which are $1.25 each; at Costco, a three-piece set of stainless steel mixing bowls is about $15, or $5 each. Dollar Tree has a fair amount of other kinds of mixing and prep bowls too, including glass prep bowl sets, which you likely won’t find at Costco — at least not all the time.”
If you can’t get going in the morning without your coffee, you’ve probably already figured out you should skip the drive-thru of the local shop and brew your own. And while it’s convenient to have the 40-ounce bag of Kirkland Signature Medium Roast on hand ($14.99 per package), is it really the best buy? Probably not, unless you’re brewing enough for a large group of coffee drinkers at the office.
Martha Stewart’s website reports that, according to the National Coffee Association, ground coffee begins to lose its flavor about one week after its sealed container is open if it’s a dark roast, or after two weeks for other roasts. In fact, the association recommends buying smaller quantities of coffee more often.
Instead, Dollar Tree sells 6-ounce bags of ground coffee – the perfect size for a fresh brew at home. And 40 ounces of dollar store coffee is about half the price of Kirkland coffee.
Remember when you go to Costco next time that sometimes, good things do come in small packages.
More From GOBankingRates
- Social Security: New Bill Could Give Seniors an Extra $2,400 a Year
- See Our List: 100 Most Influential Money Experts
- Should You Still Buy a Home in Today's Market?
- 37 Life Hacks That Will Save You Money
Jami Farkas contributed to the reporting for this article.