10 States To Avoid If You’re Living on Just a Social Security Check
Social Security is an important component of the American retirement system, providing about 30% of the income of the elderly, according to the Social Security Administration. But for those living in high-cost states, this percentage is much less. In other words, if you live or plan to live in an expensive state during retirement, you’ll need much more outside income than the average $1,781.63 monthly Social Security check to cover your costs.
To find out which are the 10 worst states to live on a Social Security check, GOBankingRates analyzed data on rental rates for a one-bedroom apartment and the overall cost of living from a variety of sources, including the Social Security Administration, the 2022 Missouri Economic Research and Information Center’s Cost-of-living data series and ApartmentList’s February 2023 data.
The most expensive states, as determined from the data, are listed here in reverse order. Perhaps not surprisingly, the bulk of the states on the list are in coastal areas.
- 2022 average 1-bedroom rent: $1,411
- Cost-of-living index: 102.8
Florida actually ranks pretty well on its overall cost-of-living index, but high rents push it into the more unaffordable category for those living on just a Social Security check.
Social Security: Proposal for $2,400 Extra in Checks Expanded and Reintroduced in Congress
Read: 6 Big Shakeups to Social Security in 2023
- 2022 average 1-bedroom rent: $1,300
- Cost-of-living index: 114.2
Costs jump up to more than 14% above the national average in Washington, making it more unaffordable for many retirees. However, lower-than-expected rents can make living on a limited income more manageable.
Social Security: No Matter Your Age, Do Not Claim Benefits Until You Reach This Milestone
- 2022 average 1-bedroom rent: $1,278
- Cost-of-living index: 116.8
Connecticut has a fairly high cost of living overall, and it’s famous for its high property taxes. However, if you’re a renter, things look a bit better, as Connecticut has the lowest average one-bedroom rent of any state in the top-10-most-unaffordable list.
- 2022 average 1-bedroom rent: $1,312
- Cost-of-living index: 116.1
New Hampshire is another state with a relatively low average one-bedroom rent compared to its fairly high cost of living. Although overall costs might be overwhelming for those living on Social Security, renters have a better go of it if they can trim their other expenses.
- 2022 average 1-bedroom rent: $1,498
- Cost-of-living index: 112.4
Costs in New Jersey are high, especially when it comes to real estate taxes, which are the highest in the country. One-bedroom rents are also high, so there’s no place to hide when it comes to living in New Jersey on just Social Security.
Social Security: 20% Cuts to Your Payments May Come Sooner Than Expected
- 2022 average 1-bedroom rent: $1,401
- Cost-of-living index: 124.0
Rents are high in Maryland but additional costs also take a dramatic jump, running 24% above the national average. This makes the overall cost of living in Maryland nearly twice as high as in New Jersey, relative to the national average.
- 2022 average 1-bedroom rent: $1,395
- Cost-of-living index: 149.7
The cost-of-living index in Massachusetts is actually the second-highest in the country, behind only outlier Hawaii. However, its one-bedroom rents are actually surprisingly affordable on a relative basis, helping keep the state a notch or two below the most expensive states.
- 2022 average 1-bedroom rent: $1,614
- Cost-of-living index: 134.5
New York lives up to its reputation as one of the most expensive states in the country, and it’s tough for relying primarily on Social Security to make it there. But New York is a big and diverse state, and there are plenty of areas away from Manhattan and other more expensive areas that can help your money stretch a bit further.
Retirement Savings: Experts Say This Magic Number Is the Key — and It’s Not $1 Million
- 2022 average 1-bedroom rent: $1,626
- Cost-of-living index: 137.6
California is the most expensive state in the continental U.S. for those trying to live off a Social Security check. But just like in New York, if you can get away from the big cities like San Francisco and Los Angeles, you can find your costs drop dramatically in areas like the Central Valley.
- 2022 average 1-bedroom rent: $1,772
- Cost-of-living index: 184.0
Hawaii’s overall cost of living is simply off the chart. The state’s COL index of 184 makes it more than twice as expensive (relative to the average) as the No. 2 state on the list, California. Hawaii’s average one-bedroom rent is the most expensive in the nation.
More From GOBankingRates
- 10 Aldi Brand Products Worth Buying
- See GOBankingRates' Top 100 Most Influential Money Experts and Get Advice
- 3 Things You Must Do When Your Savings Reach $50,000
- What's the Best Small Business in Your State? Vote for Your Favorite
Methodology: GOBankingRates determined the worst states to live on only a Social Security check based on the (1) average monthly benefit for retired workers, $1,781.63, sourced from Social Security Administration; (2) the overall cost of living in each city, sourced from the Missouri Economic Research and Information Center’s 2022 Cost of Living data series ; and (3) the average 2023 rent for a one bedroom apartment as sourced from ApartmentList’s February 2023 data. Factors (2) and (3) were scored and combined with the highest score being the worst. All data was collected and is up to date as of April 3, 2023.