What Would Happen if Americans Stopped Using Credit Cards? ChatGPT Reveals 5 Major Economic Shifts

©Shutterstock.com

Commitment to Our Readers

GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.

20 Years
Helping You Live Richer

Reviewed
by Experts

Trusted by
Millions of Readers

Credit cards are one of the most widely used financial tools in the United States. They shape how people spend, borrow and build credit. So, it’s fair to wonder what would happen if Americans suddenly stopped using them.

To explore the scenario, we asked ChatGPT to break down the consequences. To give you the best answer, ChatGPT laid out the big-picture effects, and we verified the key numbers with data from the Federal Reserve, the Bureau of Economic Analysis and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

Here’s how the AI explained the changes Americans would see almost immediately. What it found shows just how deeply credit cards are woven into the U.S. economy.

1. Consumer Spending Would Fall Fast

Credit cards account for a large share of short-term, day-to-day spending. Without them, Americans would be limited to cash, debit cards or whatever money is already in their accounts. Because consumer spending makes up roughly two-thirds of the U.S. GDP, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis, this aligns with ChatGPT’s claim that removing a major payment channel would slow demand across the economy.

Travel, retail, restaurants and other discretionary categories would feel the slowdown first, ChatGPT said, noting that millions of households rely on revolving credit to smooth out monthly expenses. Removing that option would likely dampen demand almost overnight.

2. Banks Would Lose Major Revenue

ChatGPT said banks would feel the impact quickly because credit card issuers rely heavily on interest charges, annual fees and interchange fees for revenue. As such, removing credit cards from the system would wipe out a major income source and could push lenders to raise fees on other products, tighten credit standards or scale back rewards programs.

Federal Reserve data supported the scale of that exposure. The Fed’s G.19 report showed Americans hold more than $1 trillion in revolving credit, the majority of which it tied to credit cards, according to the Federal Reserve. Eliminating that revenue stream would represent a significant loss for card issuers.

3. Rewards Programs Would Likely Shrink Rapidly

ChatGPT said credit card rewards would be among the first things to unravel if consumers stopped using cards. It noted that rewards programs depend heavily on interchange fees and interest charges, and removing credit card transactions would disrupt the funding behind travel points, cash back and airline partnerships.

The logic aligns with how rewards programs are structured today. Interchange fees — paid by merchants each time a customer swipes a card — help fund welcome bonuses, elevated earning categories and also with airline and hotel partnerships. Without that revenue, ChatGPT claimed rewards would likely shrink quickly, and the travel hacking ecosystem built around them would fade.

4. It Would Become Harder To Build Credit

ChatGPT said credit scores would be another area affected by the loss of credit cards. The AI explained that for many Americans, credit cards are one of the simplest ways to establish a credit history because they report monthly and allow borrowers to show responsible repayment behavior.

This aligns with how the FICO scoring model works. Payment history, credit utilization and length of credit history are major factors in determining a score, and credit cards directly influence all three. Without them, ChatGPT said younger adults and people new to credit would have fewer tools to build or improve their scores, which could make qualifying for mortgages, auto loans or even apartment leases more difficult.

5. Buy Now, Pay Later Would Surge

ChatGPT said Buy Now, Pay Later services would likely expand quickly if consumers stopped using credit cards. The AI noted that BNPL providers such as Affirm, Klarna and Afterpay could fill the gap for shoppers who want to split payments without relying on revolving credit.

Recent data from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau supported the trend of rising BNPL adoption. In its January 2025 report, the CFPB found 21.2 percent of consumers with a credit record used at least one BNPL loan in 2022, and many held multiple loans at once. That growth pattern aligned with ChatGPT’s point that BNPL could become a dominant option for retail and online purchases. However, these services don’t always help build credit, and can make it easier to take on more debt than expected.

Share This Article: