6 Must-Try Desserts for Christmas at Costco in 2025

Marvin Samuel Tolentino Pineda / iStock.com

Commitment to Our Readers

GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.

20 Years
Helping You Live Richer

Reviewed
by Experts

Trusted by
Millions of Readers

Christmas comes with plenty of tasks already, so dessert should be the easy part. Costco has many favorites for the holidays that look good, taste even better, and save valuable time and money in a busy season.

Here are six must-try desserts for Christmas to look for this year.

Also see three holiday dinner recipes to feed your family for less than $25.

Ferrara’s Bakery New York Cheesecake, 2-Pack

• Price: $99.99

This classic New York-style 8-inch cheesecake is made with Philadelphia cream cheese and sour cream, which gives each slice a smooth, velvety finish that feels properly indulgent for the holidays. The graham cracker crust stays firm, and the filling has a balanced sweetness that appeals to a broad crowd. Since the two 8-inch cakes store well in the fridge for several days, this set is a practical choice for households hosting multiple gatherings.

Libanais Baklava Assortment

• Price: $39.99

Rooted in centuries of pastry tradition, this baklava assortment brings a lovely sense of celebration to the holiday table. Crisp golden layers, finely chopped nuts and lightly sweetened syrup create a warm, rich flavor that suits winter gatherings. The box includes 100 small pastries in different shapes and textures, which makes it easy for guests to sample a bit of everything without committing to a full slice.

David’s Cookies 10-Inch Rainbow Cake

• Price: $72.99

This rainbow cake delivers a cheerful burst of color with five bright layers tucked beneath light vanilla icing. The first slice reveals a vivid stripe pattern that will delight both kids and adults, which makes it a natural centerpiece for festive gatherings. The cake stays soft and moist with a sweetness that does not overwhelm the palate. At 10 inches, it offers plenty to share, which makes it a reliable option for celebrations of all sizes.

Classic Cake Limoncello Sizzle-Cut Cake

• Price: $54.99

This limoncello cake layers ladyfingers soaked in lemon syrup with white chocolate mousse and a glossy lemon curd that adds just the right amount of sparkle. The eight pre-cut slices look polished thanks to the white chocolate shavings on top, which gives it a clear special-occasion feel. Light, citrusy and gently indulgent, it is the type of dessert that tends to disappear once people have their first taste.

Mary Macleod’s Gluten-Free Shortbread Cookies

• Price: $49.99

Mary Macleod’s puts a gourmet twist on gluten-free baking with a selection of shortbread cookies made from premium almond and coconut flours. The assortment includes classic buttery rounds and chocolate topped crunch varieties, all with a delicate texture that closely mirrors traditional shortbread. Each cookie holds its shape well and comes neatly packed, which makes them simple to set out on dessert trays during the holidays.

Collin Street Bakery Mini Pecan Cake Bundle

• Price: $49.99 (regularly $59.99)

The Collin Street Bakery mini pecan cake bundle features individually sized cakes made with the bakery’s signature mix of pecans, fruit and warm spices. Each mini cake has a dense, moist texture with plenty of nuts in every bite, which gives it a traditional holiday flavor. The small portions make serving easy and help keep each cake fresh, which is ideal for households with guests coming and going throughout the week.

Editor’s note: Pricing and availability may vary depending on location.

Share This Article: