What Is a Fixed Index Annuity?

SelectStock / iStock.com

Commitment to Our Readers

GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.

20 Years
Helping You Live Richer

Reviewed
by Experts

Trusted by
Millions of Readers

A fixed index annuity (FIA) balances between security and growth potential by linking returns to a stock market index while protecting against market downturns. It’s a popular choice for retirement planning because it provides tax-deferred growth and guaranteed income options.

But is a fixed index annuity the right investment for you? This guide will explain how fixed index annuities work, their benefits and risks and when they may or may not be a smart choice.

How Does a Fixed Index Annuity Work?

A fixed index annuity combines elements of fixed annuities (which offer stable, guaranteed interest) and variable annuities (which have market exposure). Instead of earning a fixed interest rate, the return on a fixed index annuity is tied to a stock market index, like the S&P 500.

Key Features of a Fixed Index Annuity

• Principal Protection – Even if the market crashes, you won’t lose your initial investment.
• Market-Linked Growth – Potential to earn more than traditional fixed annuities.
• Tax-Deferred Earnings – Interest grows tax-free until withdrawn.
• Guaranteed Income Options – Can provide lifetime income in retirement.

You can pay an additional amount for a “guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit” that pays you a regular income. The payments increase yearly, for up to 10 years, as long as you don’t withdraw money. You can also opt to have some of your money go into a fixed account paying a guaranteed interest rate. These options are added to your contract as riders for which you’ll pay an additional fee.

Growth within a fixed index annuity is tax-deferred, meaning you don’t pay taxes on the gains until you withdraw the funds.

Some fixed index annuities — called equity-indexed annuities — invest in equities and are regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission. As such, they’re vulnerable to market forces that could result in you losing some of your investment. In the case of an S&P 500-linked annuity that invests in stocks, for example, a negative growth index results in negative annuity growth of the annuity.

How Do Fixed Index Annuities Work?

Fixed annuities may sound like complex financial products, but they aren’t so complicated if you dive into some of the basics.

Here’s how they work:

Basic Structure

Annuities have two phases, as the SEC explains. The first is an accumulation phase, when you pay the premium, whether as a lump sum or a series of payments. The insurance company puts your money into the indexed investment, where it grows (or shrinks) as the investment grows and shrinks. The return, whether positive or negative, is calculated over a specific period, usually 12 months.

Fixed annuities have the same monthly payment and are more affordable. Variable and indexed annuities are more expensive, but you can earn higher returns from these financial products. Variable annuities use mutual funds to potentially boost returns, while indexed annuities turn to a benchmark like the S&P 500.

The second phase is the annuity phase. This pays out money to you, either as a lump sum or in periodic payments — whichever your contract specifies.

Growth and Guarantees

The growth rates from variable and indexed annuities are based on market performance. However, the insurance company doesn’t necessarily credit your annuity with the full amount of the index’s gain. And while fixed index annuities are designed to protect your principal if the index declines, your annuity could lose more than the index did. That’s because of the way returns are calculated.

According to the SEC, dividends are usually excluded from the gains calculations, so if the index gains 5% but 2% of that comes from dividends, your annuity would only recognize a 3% gain.

In addition, the insurance company restricts positive gains to a percentage of the index’s performance by one or more of the following means:

• Participation rate: This is the percentage of the gain credited to your annuity. A 75% participation rate and a 10% gain, for example, would result in your annuity being credited a 7.5% gain (.10 x .75).
• Rate cap: This is the maximum positive return your contract allows. If the cap is 7.5% and the gain is 5%, your annuity can be credited with the whole 5%. If, on the other hand, the cap is 7.5% and the gain is 10%, your annuity can only be credited with 7.5%.
• Fees: Various fees, whether they’re called administrative fees, asset fees or margins/spreads, take a certain percentage from your annuity. If your annuity has a 2% spread and the index gains 6%, your annuity will be credited with a 4% gain — 6% less the 2% spread.

Many fixed equity-indexed annuities limit losses if the index declines in value. For example, your annuity might have a “floor,” which is the opposite of a rate cap — instead of capping the amount of positive return, it specifies the largest decline your annuity can suffer.

In addition, the contract might specify a buffer, or shield, which is the percentage of a loss that the insurance company will cover. If that buffer is 2% and the loss is 10%, the insurance company would adjust your annuity’s value based on an 8% decline.

Payout Options

You can make a lump sum payment for an annuity and start receiving passive income. However, if you don’t have enough for a lump sum payment, you can make flexible payments and pay the lump sum over time.

Annuities pay out people in monthly, quarterly or annual intervals. Policyholders can set themselves up with lifetime income through an annuity.

Fixed Index Annuity vs. Other Annuities

There are some key differences between fixed index annuities and other annuities. Here’s a breakdown:

Fixed Index Annuity Pros and Cons

A fixed index annuity significantly impacts your retirement income. Understanding the pros and cons helps ensure the impact is positive if you invest.

Pros

Here are several reasons to consider adding a fixed index annuity to your retirement portfolio:

• Growth Potential with Protection – Earn market-linked returns with no risk of loss.
• Tax Advantages – Interest compounds tax-free until withdrawal.
• Lifetime Income Options – Can be structured to provide guaranteed income for life.
• No Market Risk – Unlike stocks, your principal is protected from losses.

Cons

The downsides of fixed index annuities are deal breakers for some investors.

• Growth Caps and Participation Limits – You won’t receive full market gains.
• High Fees – Some FIAs have rider fees and surrender charges.
• Limited Liquidity – Early withdrawals may result in penalties and surrender charges.
• Complex Terms – Can be difficult to understand without professional guidance.

How to Evaluate and Purchase a Fixed Index Annuity

Some fixed index annuities are better than others and it’s good to assess several options before deciding which one is right for you.

Here’s what to consider before committing to an annuity:

Understanding Terms

Policyholders should review each fixed index annuity’s caps, spreads and participation rates to gauge how much they can earn from an annuity. It’s also important to compare each annuity’s surrender charges and fees to see how they’ll impact your total returns.

Choosing a Provider

When choosing a provider, you shouldn’t just stop at comparing terms. It’s also important to gauge an insurance provider’s financial health to ensure they can keep up with the monthly payments. Ask the insurer about their financial strength rating to see if they’re in a good position.

When FIAs Are a Good Choice:

• You’re near retirement and want growth without risk.
• You need a guaranteed lifetime income stream.
• You want tax-deferred growth with market exposure.

When FIAs Might NOT Be a Good Fit:

• You need high liquidity (early withdrawals may be penalized).
• You seek higher returns (traditional stocks and ETFs may offer more upside).
• You don’t understand how caps, spreads and participation rates impact earnings.

Are Fixed Index Annuities a Good Investment?

The quality of any investment depends on your long-term financial goals and immediate needs.

Here’s what to consider before deciding if annuities are right for you:

When They May Be Suitable

Fixed index annuities are optimal for retirees looking to reduce risk while opening the door to potential growth opportunities. These financial products have great downside protection and can offer steady, passive income in retirement.

When They May Not Be a Good Fit

Fixed index annuities don’t make as much sense for young investors seeking to maximize their returns. Young investors who aren’t afraid of taking risks shouldn’t get annuities. Annuities also aren’t good for people who need more liquidity. These financial products currently have surrender charges that result in a hefty fee if you want to pull your lump sum out of the annuity.

Which Is Better, a Fixed Annuity or a Fixed Index Annuity?

A fixed annuity earns a guaranteed interest rate during the annuity’s accumulation phase, and it guarantees specific payment amounts during the annuity phase. That predictability makes retirement planning easier because you know exactly how much you’ll get and how long you’ll get it.

A fixed index annuity, on the other hand, is unpredictable because the annuity’s value rises and falls with the index it tracks. While it leaves you with gaps in your income if the index performs worse than you anticipated, it can also lead to larger gains if the index performs well.

If you like predictability and have a lower risk tolerance, you’ll probably prefer a fixed annuity. If you can afford to take a chance on the markets and want to maximize your income, a fixed index annuity might be the better choice.

How To Buy a Fixed Index Annuity

You can buy a fixed index annuity through a financial advisor, investment brokerage or insurance company. A fee-only advisor might be your best bet because they don’t earn a commission on the sale. A fee-only advisor serves as your fiduciary, meaning they put your interest above their own when recommending products.

Remember that no matter how you buy it, an annuity is an insurance contract, so it’s vital that you read the contract thoroughly before you invest. Equity-indexed annuities will have a prospectus, which is a document that contains all the information you need about an investment to make an informed decision about whether to buy in. The SEC advises investors to also review the prospectus carefully so that they fully understand each of the annuity’s features and its potential impact on the annuity’s return.

Final Thoughts to GO: Is a Fixed Index Annuity Right for You?

A fixed index annuity can be a solid retirement strategy for those who:

• Want market exposure with no risk of loss
• Need steady, tax-deferred growth.
• Prefer a guaranteed lifetime income

However, FIAs come with complex terms, limited liquidity, and growth caps — so they’re not for everyone. Compare your options carefully and consult a fiduciary financial advisor before making a decision.

Information is accurate as of Feb. 19, 2025.

Editorial Note: This content is not provided by any entity covered in this article. Any opinions, analyses, reviews, ratings or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the author alone and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any entity named in this article.

Share This Article: