Should You Stop Using Autopay in 2026? Experts Weigh In
Written by
Jordan Rosenfeld
Edited by
Molly Sullivan
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
If you think autopay is helping you stay organized, experts say you may want to take another look. While autopay has the benefit of making sure you don’t miss payments, it can also cause problems.
As costs fluctuate and companies raise prices more frequently, automatic payments can make it harder to stay on top of your finances, leading to unexpected or mistimed expenses. Should you stop using autopay in 2026? Experts weighed in on the pros and cons.
Autopay Isn’t the Enemy
Autopay can still be useful in 2026, said Taylor Kovar, founder and CEO of 11 Financial, but only if consumers stop treating it as a “set-it-and-forget-it” system. Bob Chitrathorn, CPFA, CFO and vice president of wealth planning at Simplified Wealth Management, added that, “Autopay has turned into auto-ignore … The biggest danger of autopay is that it lulls people into a false sense of control.”
Rising costs, subscription creep and billing errors make passive spending more dangerous than ever. Use it only if you’re not putting autopay on autopilot.
The Hidden Risks of Autopay: Billing Errors, Price Hikes and Overdrafts
Experts warned that autopay can quietly mask financial problems or habits. Not only can autopay “desensitize you toward spending,” which contributes to overspending, said Adem Selita, co-founder of The Debt Relief Company, it can mask errors.
“A potential risk with autopay is billing mistakes that go unnoticed, like a double charge coming in, a subscription price increase without notice, or a service you thought had been canceled keeps charging you,” said Hector Castaneda, a CPA and principal at Castaneda CPA & Associates. “Autopay hides all that.”
For people on tighter budgets, even a small change can trigger overdrafts or force unintended credit card use, Selita warned.
Autopay and Overspending: How Automation Masks Cash-Flow Problems
Autopay can debit accounts faster than people expect, especially as bills rise in 2026. “When money is tight, every dollar counts and autopay doesn’t wait for you to be prepared,” Castaneda said. If several autopay charges come in before your paycheck clears, you can wind up in the red, he stressed.
When Autopay Helps You and When It Hurts You
Some payments are better suited for autopay, Chitrathorn said, such as “fixed essential bills like mortgage and car loan payments.”
Castaneda warned that using autopay for credit cards can be risky “because if you’re not keeping an eye on your spending, autopay might deduct a high balance that will catch you off guard.”
Selita finds it more useful for subscriptions you intend to renew.
Who Should Avoid Autopay in 2026?
Autopay isn’t ideal for consumers who need tight control over their cash flow, especially those with fluctuating income or high-interest debt, Chitrathorn said. “If your income fluctuates, or you’re juggling high-interest debt, autopay can create a timing mismatch that leads to overdrafts or missed opportunities to prioritize smarter spending.”
High-interest balances also require more active monitoring. As Selita noted, “Debt is typically something that should be reviewed with a fine-tooth comb and not left to fester.”
Castaneda also urged being careful with discretionary spending is another area where experts recommend caution. “Anything that is simply a desire — not a need — should not be put into a subscription model…”
If You Keep Autopay in 2026, Adopt These Monitoring Habits
Using autopay requires oversight, full stop. Consumers who keep it should check their statements monthly, Castaneda said, to spot increases or unusual charges. It’s also a good idea to set up alerts on your bank accounts and credit cards so you’re not surprised by autopay charges.
Kovar also recommended a monthly subscription audit. And don’t “just glance, review every line item,” Chitrathorn urged.
How To Safely Stop Autopay Without Missing Payments
If someone decides to turn off autopay in 2026, be sure to replace the automation with structure, Castaneda said, otherwise you risk late fees and missed payments. This can include creating a payment calendar, on paper or digitally.
“Try a one-month transition where you keep autopay active but manually track the payments,” he added.
For anyone using autopay in 2026, Kovar concluded with the advice “to keep using it for the predictable stuff, stay alert for surprises and check in with your money often enough that nothing catches you off guard.”
More From GOBankingRates
