3 Key Signs This Budgeting Method Is Working Against You
Written by
Cindy Lamothe
Edited by
Amber Barkley
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
All budgeting strategies have their positives and negatives. There really is no “one size fits all,” and what may be preferred by one person might be hated by another.
According to Adem Selita, CEO and co-founder of The Debt Relief Company, zero-based budgeting can be problematic in that it’s often time-consuming and has a high likelihood of burnout and abandonment. “Zero-based budgeting can sometimes be too rigid and might not sufficiently account for consumers that have varying incomes. Life isn’t always a straight line, as much as we may want it to be.”
Below are some key signs this budgeting method may be working against you.
It’s Become Financial Micromanagement
“Zero-based budgeting burns people out when it turns into financial micromanagement,” said Kevin Shahnazari, founder and CEO of FinlyWealth.
He offered the example of tracking your coffee purchases — you might start to feel anxiety over the spending, rather than control. “My clients who obsess over small purchases often miss bigger financial opportunities, like negotiating better insurance rates or investing in their careers.”
You’re Prioritizing Tracking Expenses Over Financial Planning
“When budgeters spend more time logging transactions than planning their financial future, they’re missing the forest for the trees,” said Shahnazari. “I’ve found that people who spend hours categorizing minor expenses could better use that time learning about investments or exploring side income opportunities.”
He noted that the most successful budgeters focus on big-picture money moves rather than penny-perfect tracking. “My alternative approach helps clients prioritize their top five spending categories while letting smaller purchases flow naturally within reasonable limits.”
You’re Depleting Your Mental Energy
“Mental bandwidth is a finite resource,” Shahnazari explained. “Spending it all on detailed expense tracking leaves no energy for wealth-building activities.”
He added that people who so closely monitor their budgets might avoid taking risks that could help them increase their income. Those risks should be calculated, but but avoiding them entirely could keep you from building wealth.
Why You Should Try Alternative Approaches
According to Dmitriy Aseev, payments technology at JPMorgan Chase & Co. and author at Money Knack, when people first start budgeting, they often misunderstand it as imposing hard restrictions on themselves, slashing expenses across the board in an effort to create the “perfect” budget.
“While this might seem effective on paper, it often strips the enjoyment out of everyday life, making budgeting feel like a dreary and unsustainable chore,” he said.
Instead, he explained that budgeting should be approached as a tool for understanding your financial habits. “Try not to see it as a strict set of rules or a series of sacrifices that drain the enjoyment out of your everyday life.”
Instead of cutting everything at once, he said to focus on understanding where your money goes.
“Track your spending to spot waste and inefficiencies while still allowing room for the things that bring you happiness,” he explained.
Opt For the ‘Pay Yourself First’ Method
If you are having trouble with a zero-based budgeting system, Selita recommended a “pay yourself first” method.
“More often than not, consumers that abandon their budget will often do so due to the rigidity of it and its lack of flexibility,” he explained.
He noted that consistency can be hard to achieve for many, and this shortfall leads to demoralization in the long term.
“With the pay yourself first method, you prioritize saving and let the chips fall where they may, with regards to the rest of your budget,” he said. “In essence, you are put into a sort of ‘financial survival mode’ and essentially force yourself to budget — in a good way, of course!”
He continued, “Oftentimes, we forget the actual goal of budgeting, which is to align spending with our longer-term goals and values. Sometimes, when we get too caught up on the method, we can lose sight of that and focus too much on the process instead of its desired outcome.”
More From GOBankingRates
