6 Best Gifts To Buy Secondhand This Holiday Season, According To Thrifting Experts

Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
Shopping secondhand for gifts is a sustainable way to give this holiday season, plus, it can save you a lot of money. You might be surprised at the variety of high-quality gifts you can find at thrift stores and on online reselling platforms.
GOBankingRates spoke with Poshmark resellers to get their advice on the best gifts to buy secondhand. Before overspending on all-new gifts, consider buying these gift items secondhand this year.
Graphic Tees
If you’re looking for a unique gift, consider a thrifted graphic T-shirt.
“Secondhand graphic tees are truly one of a kind,” said Rheeana Miles, a Gen Z Poshmark seller from Lancaster, Pennsylvania. “What are the odds someone else has the same vintage graphic tee as you?”
College Sweatshirts
Whether you’re buying a gift for a college student or just a fan of college sports, a thrifted college sweatshirt can be a great option.
“College attire is so much better secondhand versus new because of how unique each piece is,” Miles said. “When you pull that college sweatshirt over your head to represent your team, you’re also representing all the memories it carried before you. You’re living a legacy through the sweatshirt when it comes to you secondhand.”
Coffee Mugs and Wine Glasses
Coffee mugs and wine glasses make for excellent hostess gifts as well as small gifts for gift exchanges — and they’re a great option to buy secondhand.
“Mugs and glasses are easy to find secondhand and easy to sanitize,” said Octavia Joseph, a nurse and part-time reseller in Lafayette, Louisiana. “These items normally have little to no wear.”
Men’s Ties
If you want to buy a tie for a man in your life without the high department store prices, consider buying one secondhand.
“Men’s ties are affordable versus new, and often have little to no wear because it’s typically worn against clothing,” Joseph said. “You can find brand names at much cheaper prices.”
Limited-Edition Toys
You can find toys you won’t find anywhere else when you buy secondhand.
“A rare Barbie doll or a limited-edition toy car would make wonderful gifts for a child or avid collector, and the beauty of secondhand is you can find items like these that are no longer in stock to purchase directly from the manufacturer,” said Chenelle Loggins, a seller and author of “From Retail to Resell: How I Turned My Passion into Profit.”
Luxury Gifts
If you want to gift someone a luxury item, consider purchasing it secondhand for major savings.
“Shopping secondhand allows you the opportunity to gift someone or yourself something that you normally couldn’t afford full price, like a cashmere sweater, a silk scarf or a designer watch,” Loggins said. “You can find amazing gifts like these deeply discounted by shopping secondhand — and the best part is you won’t have to break the bank.”
More From GOBankingRates