Should You Buy a Tesla or a Hybrid Car? Here’s What an Expert Says
Written by
Joel Lim
Edited by
Rebekah Evans
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
For consumers, the automotive landscape has never been more complex.
One of the reasons for this is that car buyers find themselves weighing the merits of electric vehicles like Tesla against hybrid alternatives. This is more than just choosing a car; it’s about selecting a technology that will define your driving experience for years to come.
Choosing between a Tesla and a hybrid car can be genuinely challenging. Both options present distinct advantages and drawbacks. The decision becomes even more challenging when considering factors like cost, driving habits and whether you want to own or lease.
Let’s try to make the choice between buying a Tesla or a hybrid easier. We asked an automotive expert for their thoughts.
Expert Weighs In: Tesla vs. Hybrid Cars
“Honestly, deciding between a Tesla (or any other electric vehicle [EV] vehicle for that matter) and a hybrid can be a tough call and this is because both of these options come with different pros and cons,” said Ruth Calkins, general manager at FindByPlate.
“On the one hand, a hybrid tempts with the prospect of getting the best of both worlds fully blended in one vehicle. But in reality, this seeming advantage tends to be any hybrid’s greatest flaw. This is because of the complexities of having to integrate two separate powertrains into a single vehicle,” Calkins explained.
“Not only does this raise the production cost of hybrid vehicles, but it often impacts the vehicle’s fuel efficiency. It also makes ongoing maintenance more expensive,” Calkins added.
When it comes to Tesla, Calkins has other thoughts. “With Tesla, price isn’t just the only thing that buyers would have to be worried about; they will also have to consider range, battery durability and longevity,” Calkins explained.
“My opinion is that when it comes to vehicles, there is hardly one size fits all. I believe when it comes to choosing between a Tesla or a Hybrid, it makes more sense, both financially and otherwise, to choose a Tesla,” Calkins added. “At least with a Tesla, buyers would know exactly what they are getting into, because along with this vehicle’s less complex build comes greater predictability, reliability and a straightforward maintenance schedule.”
Considerations With Tesla
Tesla Requires Less Maintenance
Tesla has over-the-air diagnostics and fewer moving parts. At the same time, hybrid cars have many more nodes in order to combine the functions of an electric and gasoline vehicle. This is why Tesla requires far fewer regular maintenance interventions and unexpected repairs.
Tesla Has Highly Durable Batteries
Tesla’s battery packs are designed to last with superior thermal management, ensuring used car customers are comfortable with range stability. Tesla’s battery packs are liquid-cooled, which keeps cells in the appropriate temperature range, reducing degradation over time.
A study by Green Car Reports show that a majority of Tesla battery packs retain over 88% capacity after 200,000 miles. On the other hand, hybrid batteries are smaller and discharge more often, which means they lose capacity much faster.
Considerations With Hybrid Cars
Hybrids Hold Their Value Better Compared To Tesla
Recent market data adds nuance. A study by the George Washington University shows that models like the Tesla Model S and Model 3 can depreciate faster than many hybrids, sometimes losing more than 60% of value in five years, largely due to price cuts on new vehicles and a growing EV supply.
Hybrids Are More Resilient in Cold Climates
While hybrids rely on their combustion engine to warm the cabin and operate consistently in sub-zero temperatures, Tesla’s generate all their heat from the battery, which impacts range.
Tesla will only work well in more moderate climates, but less practical in some areas of the U.S., particularly the Northeast, Upper Midwest and Mountain West, with their long winters and subzero temperatures.
Making the Right Choice for Your Needs
Buyers who prioritize simplicity, lower maintenance costs and environmental impact may find Tesla’s approach more appealing. The straightforward ownership experience and proven battery durability make electric vehicles increasingly attractive for many consumers.
However, buyers in cold climates and those concerned about resale values or drivers who frequently travel long distances without reliable charging infrastructure, might find hybrids better suited to their needs. At least this way, you can switch to petrol if your battery is starting to run low.
More From GOBankingRates
