10 Amazing Big Cities for Renters in 2023

Good news for renters — rent prices have finally started to cool thanks to an increase in supply, according to a recent study from HouseCanary. The median national rent was $2,305 at the end of 2022, and although that marks a 4.8% increase from 2021, that’s a 5.9% decrease from the end of the first half of 2022, the study found.
With rent prices cooling, it’s now cheaper to rent than own in several major cities across the U.S. To find the best big cities for renters, GOBankingRates looked at the rental markets across 50 major cities to find places where the rent prices are increasing at a slower rate than average, where the average annual rent is cheaper than the average annual mortgage, and where livability scores are high. Here’s a look at the best big cities for renters in 2023.
1. Columbus, Ohio
- Average monthly rent: $1,308
- Year-over-year change in rent (%): 6.4%
- Average monthly mortgage cost: $1,556
- Annual savings for renting vs. owning: $2,970
- Livability score: 73
2. San Antonio, Texas
- Average monthly rent: $1,431
- Year-over-year change in rent (%): 4.43%
- Average monthly mortgage cost: $1,837
- Annual savings for renting vs. owning: $4,869
- Livability score: 71
3. Raleigh, North Carolina
- Average monthly rent: $1,651
- Year-over-year change in rent (%): 5.85%
- Average monthly mortgage cost: $2,477
- Annual savings for renting vs. owning: $9,917
- Livability score: 74
4. Mesa, Arizona
- Average monthly rent: $1,750
- Year-over-year change in rent (%): 1.13%
- Average monthly mortgage cost: $2,331
- Annual savings for renting vs. owning: $6,971
- Livability score: 77
5. Austin, Texas
- Average monthly rent: $1,871
- Year-over-year change in rent (%): 4.22%
- Average monthly mortgage cost: $4,161
- Annual savings for renting vs. owning: $27,480
- Livability score: 72
6. Virginia Beach, Virginia
- Average monthly rent: $1,840
- Year-over-year change in rent (%): 5.17%
- Average monthly mortgage cost: $2,129
- Annual savings for renting vs. owning: $3,466
- Livability score: 79
7. Milwaukee, Wisconsin
- Average monthly rent: $1,097
- Year-over-year change in rent (%): 6.29%
- Average monthly mortgage cost: $1,108
- Annual savings for renting vs. owning: $131
- Livability score: 61
8. Fort Worth, Texas
- Average monthly rent: $1,766
- Year-over-year change in rent (%): 6.27%
- Average monthly mortgage cost: $1,989
- Annual savings for renting vs. owning: $2,676
- Livability score: 73
9. Jacksonville, Florida
- Average monthly rent: $1,632
- Year-over-year change in rent (%): 6.08%
- Average monthly mortgage cost: $1,744
- Annual savings for renting vs. owning: $1,345
- Livability score: 69
10. Colorado Springs, Colorado
- Average monthly rent: $1,801
- Year-over-year change in rent (%): 4.91%
- Average monthly mortgage cost: $2,567
- Annual savings for renting vs. owning: $9,198
- Livability score: 70
Methodology: For this piece, GOBankingRates first looked at the 50 largest cities in terms of housing markets as sourced from Zillow’s December 2022 data. From there, GOBankingRates compared the 50 cities to the United States average for (1) year-over-year change in rent price in USD; (2) the percentage change in year-over-year rent, and (3) 2022 average rent. For a city to move on to the next round of rankings it had to have smaller values for factors (1) – (3) than the United States as a whole. Once these qualified (22) cities were isolated, GOBankingRates found each city’s (4) annual mortgage payment through Zillow’s mortgage calculator; assuming a 20% down payment with a 6.09% 30-year fixed rate mortgage as sourced from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis: 30-Year Fixed Rate Mortgage Average in the United States data and property taxes sourced from the Tax Foundation. GOBankingRates then found (5) the difference between an annual mortgage payment and annual rent. If the annual rent payment was the smaller figure, the city moved into the final round. In the final round, GOBankingRates found each city’s (6) livability score as sourced from Areavibes. Then, GOBankingRates scored and combined factors (3), (5) and (6), with the lowest score being the best. In final calculations, factor (3) was weighted 2x and factor (6) was weighted 1.5x. All data was collected and is up to date as of Feb. 2, 2023.
More From GOBankingRates
Share This Article:
Related Content


What's Next for Warren Buffett and Berkshire Now That 'Investing Genius' Charlie Munger Has Passed?
November 29, 2023
4 min Read


12 Vintage Jewelry Pieces in Your Collection That Could Be Worth a Lot of Money
November 29, 2023
4 min Read





Warren Buffett's Advice to Investors: 'Incredible Period' for America's Economy Is Ending
November 29, 2023
4 min Read

Sign Up For Our Free Newsletter!
Get advice on achieving your financial goals and stay up to date on the day's top financial stories.
By clicking the 'Subscribe Now' button, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can click on the 'unsubscribe' link in the email at anytime.
Thank you for signing up!


Sending you timely financial stories that you can bank on.
Sign up for our daily newsletter for the latest financial news and trending topics.
For our full Privacy Policy, click here.