The Side Hustle Trap: When the Scramble for Extra Income Keeps You Broke

domoyega / Getty Images

Commitment to Our Readers

GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.

20 Years
Helping You Live Richer

Reviewed
by Experts

Trusted by
Millions of Readers

Times are feeling tighter these days. You joke grimly about needing to refinance your mortgage to buy eggs. Every time you fill your gas tank, you wonder if you’ll eventually have to raid your 401(k) just to get to work. Maybe it’s not quite that dire — but you wouldn’t mind a little more breathing room. Life would be more comfortable, you think, if you took on a side hustle.

So, you pick up freelance gigs or start delivering for DoorDash. Maybe you even walk dogs on the weekend or sell crafts on Etsy. It’s extra income — problem solved, right?

Not always.

While side hustles can be helpful, they’re not a guaranteed path to financial stability. In some cases, they might even be holding you back. Here’s how to tell if your side hustle is doing more harm than good.

1. Your Hourly Return Isn’t Worth It 

You’re working hard, but your bank account isn’t growing in any meaningful way. You’re putting in hours — maybe just as many as your full-time job — but you wouldn’t know exactly how many because you haven’t tracked them.

After your 9-to-5, you’re grinding through your 5-to-9, or, more likely, your 5-to-midnight — your clients expect that copy, graphic design, or hand-sewn garment to be in perfect condition. Soon, a side hustle takes on the same amount of hours as a full-time gig.

You know how much you’re earning. You might even be deducting your supply costs. But have you actually crunched the numbers on your hourly rate? Do the math, and you might be horrified to find you’re making less than minimum wage.

If that’s the case, it’s time to rethink your hustle. Cut back your hours. Set clearer boundaries with clients. And consider whether your time could be better spent elsewhere.

2. The Cost of Doing Business Adds Up 

Some side hustles come with built-in costs. If you’re crafting, you need supplies. If you drive for any delivery service, you’re on the hook for gas, maintenance, and maybe even car detailing. Walk dogs? Don’t forget poop bags and advertising fees on pet-sitting platforms.

Even digital work comes with expenses. As a freelance graphic designer, social media marketer or copywriter, you might need to invest in a website, pay for a domain, hire a photographer, or take courses to stay competitive. Those small costs can add up, and if you’re not tracking them closely, they can quietly eat into your profits. 

3. You’re Not Using Your Time Strategically

Unless your side hustle is a passion project, odds are, it’ll start to feel like a time-suck after a while. You have to ask yourself whether you’d be spending your time more effectively by searching for a higher-paying full-time opportunity, whether it’s finding a job outside your company or networking internally to get promoted. A side hustle may offer quick cash, but it shouldn’t come at the expense of future growth.

4. You’re Burning Out and Making Costly Mistakes

They don’t call it the daily grind for nothing. After your full-time job, your side hustle becomes a second shift. Saying you’re tired would be putting it mildly, and in your state of exhaustion, you’re not making the savviest money decisions.

You forget to comparison shop. You miss a bill payment. You skip meal planning and start ordering out more often. It all adds up to some major subtractions in your budget. Ironically, the hustle you took on to save money ends up costing you even more.

5. You’re Avoiding the Real Problem: Your Budget 

There’s no denying that a little extra cash would make life easier in so many ways. But you might also find that, with some more careful budgeting or planning, you’d be in a position that doesn’t require a side hustle — or, at least, not so many hours devoted to one. Be careful that you’re not using your hustle to avoid the real issue: you haven’t examined why your budget isn’t working in the first place.

Bottom Line

A side hustle can be a lifeline when you need extra cash — but it shouldn’t become a trap. If it’s burning you out, costing more than it brings in or distracting you from career opportunities, it might be time to rethink your strategy. More money isn’t always the answer. Sometimes, it’s about using what you have more wisely.

Share This Article: