Manchin Says There Is a ‘Better Program’ Than Social Security and Medicare

Frustrated young couple doing paperwork in their home.
valentinrussanov / Getty Images

Commitment to Our Readers

GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.

20 Years
Helping You Live Richer

Reviewed
by Experts

Trusted by
Millions of Readers

The debate over Social Security reform has largely been framed as a partisan one, with Democrats more apt to maintain the status quo and Republicans more apt to push for fiscal changes to the program. But like many things in the nation’s capital, that take is not entirely accurate.

Within the last week, two U.S. senators who normally side with Democrats have indicated a willingness to take a look at areas where Social Security can be tweaked to put it on more secure financial footing.

One of them is Sen. Angus King, an independent from Maine who caucuses with Democrats and is working with Republican Sen. Bill Cassidy of Louisiana on a bipartisan plan to make Social Security more financially stable. The other is Sen. Joe Manchin, a West Virginia Democrat and key Senate swing vote who last week suggested he is also open to Social Security changes — as long as they don’t involve cuts to the program.

“I just think: ‘Is there a better program? Is there a better way younger people can invest and have something for retirement?'” Manchin told Fox Business. “[The] only thing I’m telling you I’m not going to discuss is cutting Social Security and Medicare for those people that are receiving and have been depending on it, that have worked hard and earned it. Now with that, you have to look at everything. How do you sustain what you have?”

After some initial backlash to those comments, Manchin spokesperson Sam Runyon told USA Today that “Manchin’s record on protecting Medicare and Social Security is crystal-clear, and he reiterated his continued support for both programs when speaking to (Fox host) Neil Cavuto today.”

Today's Top Offers

Meanwhile, Machin’s website says Social Security and Medicare “are off the table in the debt limit discussions.”

Social Security has come under increased scrutiny due to worries over how the program will be funded in the future. As previously reported by GOBankingRates, Social Security’s Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) Trust Fund is expected to run out of money as early as 2032. When that happens, the program will be solely reliant on payroll taxes for funding, which might cover only about 75% of benefits.

Lawmakers have put forth various proposals to address the problem. These typically involve some combination of raising the full retirement age, cutting monthly benefits and increasing Social Security payroll taxes.

Last week, King and Kennedy put forth two more ideas. One is to create a sovereign-wealth fund that could be funded with $1.5 trillion or more in borrowed money. If the fund fails to generate an 8% annual return, both the maximum taxable income and the payroll tax rate would be increased to ensure Social Security stays on track to be solvent for another 75 years.

Another idea is to change the formula that calculates monthly Social Security benefits from one based on a worker’s average earnings over 35 years to a formula based on the number of years spent working and paying into Social Security.

Any of these ideas would require bipartisan support to make it into law. The Republican-controlled U.S. House would need to approve legislation, and so would the Senate, where Dems hold a razor-thin edge. Then President Joe Biden would need to sign the legislation.

Today's Top Offers

BEFORE YOU GO

See Today's Best
Banking Offers

Looks like you're using an adblocker

Please disable your adblocker to enjoy the optimal web experience and access the quality content you appreciate from GOBankingRates.

  • AdBlock / uBlock / Brave
    1. Click the ad blocker extension icon to the right of the address bar
    2. Disable on this site
    3. Refresh the page
  • Firefox / Edge / DuckDuckGo
    1. Click on the icon to the left of the address bar
    2. Disable Tracking Protection
    3. Refresh the page
  • Ghostery
    1. Click the blue ghost icon to the right of the address bar
    2. Disable Ad-Blocking, Anti-Tracking, and Never-Consent
    3. Refresh the page