Reality Check: What Social Security Will and Won’t Pay For

Although most people can apply for Social Security as early as 62, the full Social Security retirement age is 65 to 67, depending on when you were born — and benefits are reduced for those who take it early. Most seniors depend on the Social Security system for much of their income, and with the average monthly check totaling less than $1,300, that’s an annual income of under $15,600. For many seniors, that means making tough choices based on what their Social Security benefits will and will not cover.
Click through to discover the true costs of retiring on Social Security.
1. Mortgage
Average monthly cost for Americans: $758
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
The largest monthly expense for most people is housing, and according to USA Today, housing costs that exceed 30 percent of your income are a sign of financial distress. The average mortgage payment gobbles up nearly 60 percent of the average Social Security check. If you’re anywhere near that ratio, consider taking on a roommate, refinancing your mortgage, moving to a more affordable part of town or downsizing.
If you can’t do any of that, find out how to maximize your Social Security income.
2. Rent
Median monthly cost for Americans: $949
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
The 30-percent rule applies to renters too, but on average they have even higher monthly housing costs than homeowners. If your rent is too high, consider the same strategies that apply to homeowners — but also consider renegotiating your rent. Reliable, stable tenants who pay on time have leverage over landlords, who are often eager to avoid the risk and expense of rolling the dice on new tenants, according to the site Realtor.
3. Car Payment
Average monthly cost for Americans: $509
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
The average new car payment rose to $509 in 2017 — and the cost of the average new car was $35,368. That’s a huge chunk of a Social Security check. Since modern cars last much longer than those built in previous generations, Fortune recommends most people — even those not living on a fixed income — consider buying used and shunning feature-rich luxury vehicles for entry-level models.
4. Car Insurance
Average monthly cost for Americans: $75
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
The average car insurance bill is about $900 a year. Yes, Social Security can cover it, but when it comes to bills, less is always better. Drivers need to factor in insurance costs before they buy or lease a car, consider higher deductibles and reduce coverage on older cars, the Insurance Information Institute recommends. Also, ask about low-mileage discounts if you don’t drive a lot, remember that good credit usually helps, and always shop around.
5. Gasoline
Average monthly cost for Americans: $29.25
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
If you drive 1,000 miles a month in a car that gets 23 mpg, you’ll spend $117 per month with gas costing $2.70 a gallon. Assuming a retiree drives one-quarter that amount, that’s $29.25 per month. Prioritize higher gas mileage when buying your next car, use apps like GasBuddy to find the best gas prices and use apps like Waze Carpool to share expenses with other drivers.
6. Public Transportation
Average monthly cost for Americans: $99.19
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
If you live in a big city, chances are you don’t even have a car and instead rely on public transportation. Those who take buses, trains and subways in the country’s 19 biggest cities spend an average of $99 per month, which leaves far more of your Social Security check intact compared with owning, fueling and maintaining a car.
Also, consider if living in a big city is the best option when living on Social Security.
7. Landline Phone
Average monthly cost for Americans: $15 to $45
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
If you’re still clinging to a landline, the average bill for unlimited local is $15 to $30 a month. When you include long-distance coverage, it jumps to $30 to $45. Landline rates continue to rise, and in 2015, CNBC revealed that bundling services often doesn’t lead to savings. Consider dropping the service, pocketing the cash and joining the huge swaths of the population who have abandoned landlines altogether.
8. Mobile Phone
Average monthly cost for Americans: Unknown
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
Four companies account for 80 percent of all cell service and, according to Consumer Reports, their pricing schemes are an intentionally confusing, constantly shifting “shell game” that most users don’t fully understand. It’s up to you to monitor data usage and consistently check for promotions; don’t expect your carrier to inform you of potential savings. Also, if you threaten to switch, your carrier might offer a “retention deal.”
9. Heating
Average monthly cost for Americans: $50
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
Americans spend 29 percent of their annual energy bill on heating, according to the U.S. Department of Energy. Visit Energy.gov’s Energy Saver for tips and strategies on increasing efficiency and lowering bills, and if you need help paying for heat, visit the National Council on Aging or Benefits.gov.
10. Cooling
Average monthly cost for Americans: $22.32
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
The U.S. Department of Energy estimates that 13 percent of the average annual energy bill goes to home cooling and air conditioning. For seniors, staying cool in the summer is as important as staying warm in the winter. Strategically placed ceiling fans and open windows will likely suffice on all but the hottest days, and regularly maintaining air conditioners will reap long-term dividends with more efficient operation and fewer repairs.
11. Cable
Average monthly cost for Americans: $103
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
With the average cable bill now topping $100 a month, remember that your cable provider is as eager as your cellphone provider to keep you on the subscriber rolls. Call, haggle, ask for promotions that are supposed to be for new customers only and threaten to cancel service. If their offers aren’t good enough, consider following through on the threat and joining the millions of “cord cutters” who have abandoned cable for streaming media services.
12. Streaming Media
Average monthly cost for Americans: $10.99
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
Streaming services like Netflix offer an ocean of options for movies, shows and other programming — all with a fraction of the bite that traditional cable takes out of your Social Security check. Want to save even more? Forgo high definition with a switch to a basic plan, and you’ll whittle your Netflix bill to $7.99 a month.
13. Internet
Average monthly cost for Americans: $60
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
You can probably lower your internet bill by buying your own modem and router instead of renting them from your service provider, according to USA Today. Also, don’t automatically opt for the fastest speed. Many people don’t even have the equipment required to notice the difference between speeds a tier or two down.
14. Groceries
Average monthly cost for Americans: $250 to $279
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
The U.S. Department of Agriculture estimates the average monthly grocery tab for people ages 51 to 70 on a modest budget is about $250 for women and $279 for men. The three surest ways to slash your bill by as much as half are to simply shop less frequently, shop only the deals and preplan your meals to reduce waste, according to USA Today.
15. Eating Out
Average monthly cost for Americans: $250
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
Americans spend as much on eating out as they do buying groceries each month. Not only might dining out frequently be as bad for your waistline as it is for your wallet, you’ll almost always save money by making meals at home. When you do dine out, first visit a site like RetailMeNot for coupons and discounts.
16. Credit Card Bills
Average monthly cost for Americans: $189
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
The average American carries $4,717 in credit card debt with interest at 15 percent, according to Time’s Money. If you made the minimum payment of $189 a month, you’d need a decade to pay in full and you’d spend more than $18,000 in interest. Instead, only charge what you can afford to pay off in full every month — or at the very least, pay more than the minimum payment whenever possible.
17. Health Club Membership
Average monthly cost for Americans: $60
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
Gym memberships are pricey, and according to USA Today, the vast majority of them go largely unused. Visit a website like Men’s Fitness or Women’s Health for free tutorials or check out effective app workouts that nearly anyone can do.
18. Lawn Maintenance
Average monthly cost for Americans: $142
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
The average cost of lawn care is far more than someone who depends on Social Security can afford, according to HomeAdvisor. Save money — and water — by reducing your lawn size. Try laying down cheap mulch or replacing some or all of your lawn with hardy local plants.
19. Medicare Part B
Average monthly cost for Americans: $134
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
Basic Medicare includes parts A and B. Most Americans don’t pay for Part A, and the standard rate for Part B is $134 a month. To get the most credits, avoid penalties and pay the lowest amount possible, sign up for Medicare as soon as you’re eligible.
20. Housekeeping Supplies
Average monthly cost for Americans: $32
Average Social Security check: $1,290.46
Pricey housekeeping products can chip away at a Social Security check every month. According to HGTV, cheap items that you probably already have make affordable substitutes. White vinegar, baking soda, rubbing alcohol and ammonia can make light work of a huge list of common household cleaning chores.
Share this article:
Related Content

10 Best Places in Washington State for a Couple To Live on Only a Social Security Check
November 28, 2023
9 min Read

Pros and Cons of Cutting Social Security's Windfall Elimination Provision
November 28, 2023
9 min Read

Social Security Cuts: 4 Programs and Services for Boomers Struggling in Retirement
November 28, 2023
9 min Read




10 Best Places in Virginia for a Couple To Live on Only a Social Security Check
November 22, 2023
9 min Read


10 Places in Louisiana for a Couple To Live on Only a Social Security Check
November 22, 2023
9 min Read



7 Social Security Shakeups You Need To Be Ready For Heading Into the New Year
November 21, 2023
9 min Read

How Big Is the Average Social Security Check of a Retiree Living in Poverty?
November 23, 2023
9 min Read


15 Best Places in Arizona for a Couple To Live on Only a Social Security Check
November 23, 2023
9 min Read
Today's Trending Picks

Cash Back at Walmart
Let this free tool pay you up to 15% cash back when you shop online.

Unlock Free Access to Top Financial Advisors Near You through WiserAdvisor's Matching!
Get matched with a top-rated financial advisor in your area to review your retirement plan today!

Get Paid to Share Your Opinion
Get paid to answer surveys, watch videos, shop online, and more.

Protect and Secure Your Wealth With A Gold IRA
Goldco is dedicated to helping clients protect their financial future with precious metals.

Access Your Home Equity With No Monthly Payments Required
Get the cash you need now and repay the loan on your own terms later.

Take Surveys. Get Paid.
$55k+ paid daily to members who share their opinion on Survey Junkie. 1) Join Free 2) Take Surveys 3) Earn Cash & Gift Cards

Next-Gen Wealth Building: Invest in Real Estate Via Arrived.
Build A Real Estate Fortune With Arrived

Search For People, Property Records & Unclaimed Money
Search For People, Property Records & Unclaimed Money with BeenVerified

Sign Up For Our Free Newsletter!
Get advice on achieving your financial goals and stay up to date on the day's top financial stories.
By clicking the 'Subscribe Now' button, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can click on the 'unsubscribe' link in the email at anytime.
Thank you for signing up!


Sending you timely financial stories that you can bank on.
Sign up for our daily newsletter for the latest financial news and trending topics.
For our full Privacy Policy, click here.