7 Key Signs Your Budget Isn’t Working

Kerkez / iStock.com

Commitment to Our Readers

GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.

20 Years
Helping You Live Richer

Reviewed
by Experts

Trusted by
Millions of Readers

We hear a lot about how challenging sticking to a budget can be, particularly when we’re new to the process, but we don’t often hear about how challenging it can be to adhere to a budget that just isn’t serving us. In fact, we may not even know the signs that a budget we’re so earnestly trying to honor is a total bust and potentially doing us more harm than good. 

GOBankingRates spoke with financial experts to learn about the seven red flags indicating your budget isn’t working — and what to do to get back on track.

You’re Dipping Into Savings or Using Credit Cards To Cover Basic Expenses

Do you find yourself dipping into savings or using credit cards to cover basic expenses? If you have, your budget is failing you. 

“If your monthly paycheck isn’t covering things like groceries, utilities or gas and you’re regularly pulling from your savings or running up your credit cards, that’s a red flag,” said Paul Miller, CPA, founder at Miller and Company, LLP. “It means your budget isn’t aligned with your actual cost of living.”

To get on track, you’ll need to get back to the basics of your budget. “Track every dollar for a full month — even the $5 coffee,” Miller said. “Then compare your fixed vs. variable expenses. You may need to cut back on discretionary spending or reassess housing or transportation costs. The goal is to ensure you’re living within your means, not beyond them.”

You’re Not Sure Where Your Money Is Going 

Money can be a lot like time in that we may look at our situation and think, “Where did it all go?” But if you find yourself wondering this fairly often, your budget is definitely not serving you. 

“This one’s common,” Miller said. “If your account balance feels like it evaporates faster than expected, your budget may be too vague, or worse, nonexistent.”

If you’re not sure where your money is going, start with a zero-based budget, “where every dollar is assigned a job, including savings and fun money,” Miller said. “Awareness is powerful. Once you know where the money is going, you can redirect it more intentionally.”

You’re Broke at the End of Every Paycheck Cycle 

Living paycheck to paycheck is all too common in the U.S., and one of the main points of a budget is to avoid or break this cycle. 

“If you’ve budgeted but you still end up having very little or nothing at all at the end of the month anyway, what you’ve budgeted aren’t actual behaviors but dreams,” said Bill London, partner at Kimura London & White LLP. “There should be some breathing room in your work budget — not survival but some breathing room.”

Tracking expenses is key to remedy this problem. “Compare reality expenses and your current budget,” London said. “You probably underestimate something as basic as food, commute or subscriptions. Get your budget into reality so it most accurately represents reality (not reality you hope it were) and make deposits into your savings cushion every month — even $50.”

You’re Not Making Progress Toward Financial Goals 

It can take a long time to reach our financial goals, particularly the big ones like saving enough for a down payment on a house or eliminating student loan debt. But we should, gradually, be making some progress as the months go by. If you’re not, something is wrong. 

“If you’ve been trying to save for a vacation, pay off debt or build an emergency fund and nothing’s growing, it’s likely your budget isn’t prioritizing those goals,” Miller said, adding that the way to solve this is to “pay yourself first, build automatic savings into your budget like it’s a bill. Even $50 or $100/month adds up over time. If debt is the issue, try the snowball or avalanche method, and make sure your monthly budget reflects a plan not just survival.”

Your Budget Feels Restrictive — Not Freeing 

The mere word “budget” can make us feel like a door slamming in our face, cutting off access to joy. But an effective budget is actually meant to be freeing, so if you feel deprived, your budget is probably broken — or at least, how you think about it is. 

“Many people view budgets as something that says, ‘No! You can’t spend money!’ Understandably, this makes the word ‘budget’ invoke feelings of restriction, shame, guilt, tension and other negative emotions,” said Emily Blain, an accredited financial counselor and the owner of Dream Big Financial Coaching. “Instead, shift your mindset to give yourself permission to spend your budgeted amounts without feeling guilty! Rather than ‘I can only spend $X on eating out,’ think ‘I can spend $X on eating out and still spend $Y on clothes without worrying about paying my bills!'” 

You Can’t Answer the Question, ‘Can I Afford To…?’

“If you have a budget but don’t know whether you can afford to add an expense or travel somewhere, your budget isn’t helping,” Blain said. “Your budget should help you clearly see trade-offs and know how much wiggle room you have when bills go up or you want to add a new subscription. If travel and vacations are important to you, then those should have a permanent home in your budget so you can save for them year-round.”

You’re Arguing With Your Partner About Money 

If you have a partner with whom you share a financial life and things have been tense lately in terms of money, a lacking budget could be to blame. 

“Budgeting isn’t just about the numbers, it’s about peace of mind,” Miller said. “If you and your partner are frequently tense or disagreeing about spending, that’s a sign the budget isn’t working for you.”

The trick is to make budgeting a team sport. “Sit down together once a month to review spending, adjust where needed, and agree on shared goals,” Miller said. “If you’re solo, find an accountability partner. A budget should help you feel more in control, not more anxious.”

Share This Article: