Why Simple 1940s Money Rule Still Outperforms Modern Budgeting
Written by
Fiona Tapp
Edited by
Cory Dudak
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
Long before budgeting apps and automated spending trackers, households in the 1940s relied on a simple financial rule: Spend less than you earn, save first and make do with what you have. Sounds simple, right?
Shaped by the Great Depression’s aftermath and World War II rationing, this mindset emphasized discipline, delayed gratification and intentional consumption. Decades later, that rule often proves more effective than many modern budgeting systems.
Why It Works
Modern budgeting methods, like the 50/30/20 rule popularized by Senator Elizabeth Warren, divide income into categories:
- Needs
- Wants
- Savings
While simple and practical, these frameworks often focus on allocation after income is received. Apps automate tracking, but they don’t necessarily change spending psychology.
According to a study published in PLOS One, people who engage in mental budgeting (a form of self-regulated financial planning) and exercise self-control tend to have better financial well-being and improved financial decision-making, which are key components of successful budgeting. Self-control helps reduce impulsive spending and supports better financial outcomes overall.
That’s where the 1940s rule excels. Instead of categorizing spending, it prioritizes restraint. The focus is not “How should I divide this money?,” but rather, “Do I truly need to spend this?”
The enduring strength of the 1940s frugality rule lies in its simplicity. It reduces complexity, limits decision fatigue and builds automatic savings habits. In contrast, many modern systems can create a false sense of control, like tracking every coffee purchase without addressing whether the purchase aligns with long-term goals.
To adopt this 1940s-style habit today, set aside cash (or separate digital “envelopes”) for each spending category like groceries, entertainment and savings, and only use the funds allocated. This creates a clear, tangible limit that helps curb overspending.
Actionable 1940s Tips for Today
Follow these old-fashioned tips to save money today:
- Live with used items: This reduces unnecessary purchases.
- Stretch meal portions: You should also try to use leftovers creatively.
- Grow fruits and vegetables: If done whenever possible, this can save on groceries.
- Simplify your wardrobe: Using a minimalist approach can create a more versatile and timeless look.
- Mend and repair clothing: Fixing rather than replacing saves money.
- Conserve energy: Being energy conscious will help lower utility bills.
- Walk or exercise at home: The cost of transportation and gym memberships quickly add up.
- Preserve excess food: Plan weekly shopping to avoid waste.
- Focus on “do more, buy less”: Practice contentment with what you have.
These habits translate 1940s frugality into actionable steps for modern living, and are practical, simple and behavior-focused. Ultimately, the old rule outperforms because it addresses behavior first and math second. In an era of frictionless digital spending, a mindset built on intention, moderation and saving before spending may be more powerful than any app.
More From GOBankingRates
