I’m a Mechanic: 5 Car Brands I’d Never Recommend To My Own Family
Written by
Laura Beck
Edited by
Molly Sullivan
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
As an expert with JustAnswer and former shop mechanic, Chris Pyle has seen the good, the bad and the expensive when it comes to car repairs. He’s answered thousands of customer questions and worked hands-on with vehicles from every major manufacturer.
“All cars need maintenance and repair,” Pyle explained. “Some cars are just difficult to work on DIY, as well as at a shop.”
When friends and family call him about car issues, they know which brands he prefers to help with, and which ones make him cringe. Here are the five brands Pyle said he would never recommend to his own family.
5 Car Brands To Avoid
Pyle’s avoid list includes some of the most prestigious names in the automotive world: Volkswagen, Mercedes Benz, Audi, Mini and Jaguar.
“I do not like working on these and would not suggest that someone purchase them,” he shared.
These aren’t necessarily bad cars in terms of performance or luxury features. But from a practical ownership standpoint, Pyle said they create headaches that most car owners don’t anticipate when they’re shopping for a vehicle.
“I am not saying they are bad cars, they are just harder to work on and to find a tech that will work on them outside of a dealership,” he explained.
Reason 1: Parts and Supplies Cost Way More
The first thing that hits owners of these brands is the sticker shock when something needs fixing.
“When it is time to do repairs and maintenance, often the parts, supplies, fluids and filters are more expensive,” Pyle said.
This isn’t just about major repairs. Even routine maintenance items like oil filters and brake pads cost significantly more for these luxury brands compared to mainstream manufacturers. The premium pricing extends to everything needed to keep these vehicles running.
Reason 2: Limited Aftermarket Options
For most car brands, you have choices when it comes to replacement parts. You can often find quality aftermarket alternatives that cost less than original equipment manufacturer (OEM) parts.
Not so with these five brands.
“Often, you cannot even get aftermarket parts for these at car parts stores like Auto Zone,” Pyle explained. “You have to buy an expensive OEM.”
This lack of competition in the parts market means owners are stuck paying premium prices with no alternatives. A simple repair that might cost $200 on a Honda could easily cost $500 or more on a Mercedes because you have no choice but to buy the expensive factory part.
Reason 3: Everything Is Harder To Access
Modern cars are packed with components under the hood, but Pyle said these luxury brands take space constraints to an extreme.
“All cars have a ton of parts crammed under the hood, often hard to access, but these makes seem to pack it all in tighter and tougher to reach,” he shared.
What should be a straightforward job becomes an expensive ordeal when mechanics have to remove multiple components just to access the part that needs fixing.
Reason 4: Professional Resources Are Limited
Even professional mechanics struggle with these brands. Pyle spends $450 monthly on car repair guides covering most makes, models and years. But even those comprehensive resources fall short for these luxury brands.
“They do not even cover these makes that well,” he said. “You often have to pay a premium for OEM service books that only cover one make.”
This means shops have to invest in brand-specific diagnostic information and training, costs that ultimately get passed on to customers.
Reason 5: Diagnostic Tools Don’t Work
Modern car repair relies heavily on computerized diagnostic tools that can communicate with a vehicle’s onboard systems. These tools work great with most car brands, but Pyle said they often fail with luxury vehicles.
“Most scan tools will not communicate with them,” he explained.
When standard diagnostic equipment can’t talk to the car’s computer systems, mechanics are forced to use expensive brand-specific tools or send customers to dealerships. This limitation makes troubleshooting problems more difficult and more expensive.
Reason 6: Overall Difficulty Level
All of these factors combine to create vehicles that are simply harder to diagnose and repair than mainstream alternatives.
“They are overall just harder to diagnose and repair,” Pyle said.
The simple truth is what might be a quick fix on a Toyota becomes a complex project on an Audi.
What This Means for Car Buyers
While these brands often offer superior performance, comfort and prestige, they come with hidden costs that extend far beyond the purchase price.
The mechanic’s perspective is valuable because it focuses on total cost of ownership rather than just initial appeal. A car that looks great in the showroom might become a financial burden when repairs are needed.
“I would rather need a part or repair on a vehicle that most any shop can get and tackle,” Pyle explained.
When any shop can work on your car using readily available parts and standard diagnostic tools, you have options. You’re not locked into expensive dealership service or forced to hunt for specialty shops.
More From GOBankingRates
