10 Best Stocking Stuffers at Five Below

Running behind on stocking stuffer shopping for the holidays? Five Below has got you covered. Not only does the discount retailer have tons of festive stocking stuffers available for less than $5 each, some of these items are eligible for Five Below’s “four for $5” savings promotion.

GOBankingRates found the top 10 stocking stuffers that will save you the most money and make this holiday season unforgettable. Don’t wait to shop these 10 must-haves. And then check out stocking stuffers at Aldi.

• Price: $5

Enjoy long-lasting hydration and sweet flavor when you wear the eos holiday collection lip balms. Each package contains two lip balms in sparkling appletini and blackberry bellini flavors. Give as a set or break them up to stuff into two stockings.

• Price: $3.25

These Lisa Frank sticker sheets are the perfect present for the sticker enthusiast in your life. 

Inside you’ll discover more than 600 stickers in all of your favorite Lisa Frank characters and designs. Add them to sticker books, trade with friends, use during arts and crafts sessions and so much more.

• Price: $3

Brighten up your self-care routine when you add this pearly plush headband to your Five Below shopping cart. 

Made from ultra soft fabric, this shocking pink headband helps keep hair pulled back so you can moisturize and wear your favorite face masks.

• Price: $5

Solar Flare body butter has gone viral on social media for being an affordable dupe of Sol de Janeiro skincare products, making them a win for stocking stuffers.

Martina, a TikTokker at @couponingwithmartina, filmed a video revealing Five Below’s three scents of Solar Flare body butter were dupes for Sol de Janeiro’s 62, 40 and 68 body creams. Regular Sol de Janeiro shoppers will know that these creams typically retail for $48 each. 

“The size and the price comparison for something that smells nearly identical — definitely a great dupe,” Martina said.

• Price: $1

At just $1 each, you won’t be able to resist buying My Beauty Spot hand creams for this year’s stocking stuffers. 

Each hand cream works to hydrate and refresh hands and comes in sweet coconut vanilla, mango sorbet and strawberry shortcake scents.

• Price: $5

Gotta catch ’em all! Shop these Pokémon Scarlet and Violet Stellar Crown trading cards and give them to your favorite anime fan. You never know which rare cards await inside every package.

• Price: $1

Five Below’s rainbow slinky toy previously made a separate GOBankingRates listicle for being a stocking stuffer that’s a lot cheaper to buy at Five Below than it is at Walmart. 

By comparison, the Walmart price tag sets shoppers back nearly $4 and isn’t available in a fun rainbow shade.

• Price: $1.50

Take advantage of Five Below’s “four for $5” promotion on holiday Nerds candy ropes while supplies last. Each rope is loaded with sweet gummy taste and plenty of crunchy Nerds to tear and share.

• Price: $1.50

Stock up on Starbucks hot cocoa drink mixes for every stocking this year. Five Below’s “four for $5” promotion makes it easy on wallets to shop for this delightful stocking stuffer.

• Price: $1.50

Teasingly give Sour Patch Kids “coal” holiday candy as a way of revealing who was on this year’s naughty list. 

The “coals” are flavored like black raspberry. This candy is also eligible for Five Below’s “four for $5” promotion while supplies last.

Editor’s note: Prices and availability are accurate as of Dec. 6, 2024, and are subject to change.