Making These Thanksgiving Mistakes Will Cost You Big

Man Taking Roast Turkey Out Of The Oven.
monkeybusinessimages / Getty Images/iStockphoto

For a holiday full of warmth, family, gratitude and great food, there can be a lot of stress, expenses and tears on Thanksgiving — and it makes sense why. A lot of planning, cooking and spending goes into preparing a meal and party that both adheres to tradition while still satisfying everyone in attendance.

Find Out: Black Friday vs. Cyber Monday: Which Has the Better Deals?
Add to Your Shopping List: What To Buy at Costco Every Day During Black Friday Weekend

Thanksgiving can be a very overwhelming experience but there are some mistakes that are easy to avoid if you plan ahead. Here are some mistakes that can make the day harder — and some advice on making sure they don’t bring down your party. 

See: 6 Holidays Purchases That You Should Only Make at Costco

You Didn’t Plan Enough Cooking Time

Turkeys take time. A lot of time. Depending on how big your turkey is, it can take anywhere from two to six hours to cook. A good rule of thumb is to budget 13 minutes per pound of turkey. If you’re not sure how much turkey to get, the recommended amount is about one to one and a half pounds per person. So, if you have 10 people coming, you can be safe with a 10-pound turkey, which will take two hours and 10 minutes to cook. Buy anything larger and you’re not just looking at wasted time, you’re looking at an emptier wallet, too. 

Make Your Money Work for You

The prep doesn’t stop there. Depending on the sides you choose, you could be looking at well over four hours for total Thanksgiving meal cook time. One piece of advice is to make a list of everything you need to make the Tuesday before, and write how long each item takes to prepare. That way, you have every item’s needs in front of you and can even split preparations between Wednesday and Thursday.

On Thursday, you can just warm a few dishes, rather than having to make everything from scratch the day of. 

You could also consider purchasing some ready-made side options. While this may feel like you’re spending more money, the time and energy you’ll save will likely outweigh the guilt of not creating everything by hand. Remember: This is a holiday for you to enjoy, too!

Find Out: Top Holiday Toys, Gadgets and More To Shop Now — And What They’ll Cost You

Make Your Money Work for You

You Took on Too Much

Just because you’re hosting doesn’t mean you have to make every dish. If the turkey is stressing you out and someone coming to your Thanksgiving gathering has made one before, don’t be afraid to put that person in charge! Ask people to bring dishes that are already prepared. You can also have food delivered or picked up from local restaurants.

Truly evaluate what you want to make, and what you have time to make — if a dish is making you miserable, ask someone else to help. Most likely, they’ll feel happy to contribute. You can even make a spreadsheet before the event with everything you need listed. Put your name to what you can comfortably take the lead on, then ask the people coming to fill in the blanks.

Creating such a list won’t just make everyone feel included, it’ll save on money as well. Hosting is a big financial responsibility and this is the perfect holiday to allow others to help out. One more tip? When you’re evaluating what dishes you really want at your celebration, consider skipping the ones that are only on your table thanks to tradition. If no one eats green bean casserole or yams, save the money and time you’d spend on prepping these dishes and put it towards other aspects of your party that everyone will love. 

Make Your Money Work for You

You Don’t Have Any Appetizers

Now that you see how long the meal is going to take, you’ll realize there’s quite a bit of time where guests are just…waiting. To keep people happy, but not totally stuffed, it’s nice to have a few starter foods out before the big meal is finished. This can be small (and easily outsourced!) so don’t think too hard about it.

Chips and salsa, pigs in a blanket, meat and cheese boards, veggies and dip, baked brie and crackers and pretty much anything else you like to snack on will do the trick. It’s easy to forget in the mix, but it’s a simple thing that makes a big difference. 

Need a lot of appetizers on a small budget? You don’t need to break the bank to keep people stuffed from the second they enter your house to the moment you leave. Check out Costco and Trader Joe’s for deals on seasonal favorites. Or consider getting some non-perishable food items or snacks from Amazon. If you overstock, you can keep the leftovers for snacks.

You’re Making Something You’ve Never Cooked Before

When it comes to the biggest home cooked meal of the year, stick to the hits. This isn’t a great time to try out a complicated recipe that looks really good, or something that involves a step you’ve never done with other recipes you’ve made. Or worse: A dish that is both complicated and costly to make. Don’t go chasing exotic ingredients right before the holiday. Please stick to the apps and mains that you’re used to. 

Pick dishes that you’ve gotten good feedback on, or just pick up something you think is delicious from the store or a restaurant. Thanksgiving isn’t about who can make the biggest production out of the meal or show off the fanciest spices — it’s just about eating good food.

You Invited Too Many People

Maybe you’ve spent the whole month of November extending invites, and now you’ve just realized you’re having 50 people over for Thanksgiving. This isn’t a disaster, but just be aware of what this means when it comes to cooking and setting the table. With 50 people coming, experts say you’ll need 50 pounds of turkey. And that means you’re going to be spending much more money than you’ll expect. Not to mention all the dietary preferences you’ll need to accommodate for. And the table space! 

Make things easier for yourself — especially during a time when social distancing is still the norm: Keep your party small and intimate. You’ll make some excellent memories and your bank account will thank you.

More From GOBankingRates

Share this article:

Make Your Money Work for You

About the Author

Sam DiSalvo is an LA-based comedian, writer and actor who's performed all over the country. Her written work has appeared in numerous digital publications. As a copywriter, she's worked with a variety of major brands including GoldieBlox and Thrive Causemetics. Sam loves dogs and is currently perusing leisure suits to buy for her corgi mix, Barry
Learn More

Best Bank Accounts for September 2022

Untitled design (1)
Close popup The GBR Closer icon

Sending you timely financial stories that you can bank on.

Sign up for our daily newsletter for the latest financial news and trending topics.

Please enter an email.
Please enter a valid email address.
There was an unknown error. Please try again later.

For our full Privacy Policy, click here.