7 Ways You’re Accidentally Committing Tax Fraud

Stressed elderly married couple sitting at table at home manage budget paying using on-line banking access analyzing finance papers, having financial problems, high taxes expenses, unpaid debt concept.
fizkes / Getty Images/iStockphoto

Not every fraud artist is a sketchy identity thief in the dark corners of the internet. In fact, you might end up committing accidental tax fraud or accidental tax evasion yourself, if you don’t pay careful attention during tax season.

Individual slip-ups usually result from negligence rather than ill intent, but either way, it will likely draw scrutiny from the IRS. The agency is serious about nipping fraud in the bud, which is why you should check and double-check your return before filing your taxes. Get the deductions and credits you’re entitled to — but make sure you do it legally.

GOBankingRates has put together this guide explaining what tax fraud is, what to do if you see it and how to avoid it by keeping your own return honest and accurate.

What Is Tax Fraud?

The IRS defines tax fraud as “intentional wrongdoing on the part of a taxpayer with the specific purpose of evading a tax known or believed to be owing.” To meet the IRS’s tax fraud definition, there must be both a tax due and owing, and fraudulent intent.

What Is Considered Tax Evasion?

Tax evasion is a category of tax fraud. The IRS defines tax evasion as “some affirmative act to evade or defeat a tax, or payment of a tax.” Affirmative acts the IRS considers evasive include concealing assets, understating or omitting income and improperly claiming credits or exemptions.

Make Your Money Work For You

Tax evasion is different than tax avoidance, which simply means using tax deductions and other loopholes that let you avoid paying taxes legally.

Ways You Might Be Accidentally Committing Tax Fraud

Do you wonder how you might be committing tax fraud? Keep reading to find out about seven tax fraud examples that might surprise you.

1. Filing a Return With Missing or Incorrect Information

It’s crucial to file complete and accurate tax returns to avoid committing tax fraud. For example, if you paid thousands of dollars to attend college this year, you might be eligible to claim an education tax credit to reduce your taxes. But don’t forget to include Form 8863 for education credits with your return. Forgetting to include the right forms or vital data such your Social Security number — or entering them incorrectly — could be the red flags that lead to an audit.

How to avoid it: Professional tax preparers or tax preparation software can help prevent inaccurate or incomplete returns. Some tax software offers built-in e-filing that won’t let you submit your forms unless all your necessary data is included.

2. Incorrectly Claiming the Earned Income Tax Credit

Claiming the earned income tax credit when you’re not eligible for it is a major IRS audit trigger. The credit is designed to offset the burden of Social Security taxes for low-to-moderate earners. Taxpayers who qualify for it can get $560 if they have no qualifying children, $3,733 for workers with one child and $6,935 for workers with three or more children.

How to avoid it: Don’t file for the EITC if you have investment income exceeding $10,300. Child support, alimony, Social Security benefits and unemployment benefits do not contribute toward earned income. Your eligibility might fluctuate from year to year, so read the requirements closely each tax season.

Make Your Money Work For You

3. Abusing Tax Shelters

A tax shelter that sounds too good to be true likely is. Often, accountants and wealth planners tempt taxpayers with vague or deceptive tax shelter “opportunities,” or offer “captive” insurance structures that are at odds with your genuine financial needs, duplicate your existing coverage or provide coverage for totally implausible events. Your barbershop in Indiana probably isn’t going to get attacked by tigers, so don’t use that excuse as a tax shelter.

“These scams can end up costing taxpayers more in penalties, back taxes and interest than they saved in the first place,” said former IRS Commissioner John Koskinen.

How to avoid it: If you find yourself in over your head on tax shelters, seek out an independent opinion from a tax expert. Abusive tax shelters have been highlighted for the past several years on the IRS’s annual “Dirty Dozen” list of tax scams.

4. Claiming the Wrong Deductions

Although job-related expense deductions have been eliminated for individuals, you can still deduct necessary business expenses if you are a small business owner or self-employed. Just make sure an expense is really necessary before you try to deduct it. If you think it’s clever to take the family along on a business trip just to deduct the vacation as a business expense, think again. When tax time rolls around, forget about claiming your family’s side trip to Disneyland.

Some commonly misused deductions — such as writing off groceries that you mistakenly thought were for clients or employees — are simple errors. But knowingly lying on your tax return to get more money invites trouble.

Make Your Money Work For You

How to avoid it: Again, tax prep software helps prevent errors, because it typically shows the deductions for which you qualify. Another good idea is to explore the IRS website, which offers tips for deducting business expenses and full breakdowns of what you can legally deduct. Key IRS documents such as Publications 334, 535 and 538 detail eligible business expenses and offer tax guides for small businesses.

5. Taking Inflated Deductions

Your chances of being audited are low. In 2022, the IRS audited 626,204 tax returns, which represented less than 0.3% of all returns filed in the calendar year 2022, the latest year for which this information is available. That might make it tempting to claim your whole basement as a home office deduction, but don’t. Even though the chances of getting audited are low, inflated deductions are still illegal.

How to avoid it: Don’t stretch the truth. If you think you’ll have trouble paying what you owe all at once, work out a payment plan or installment agreement with the IRS via its Online Payment Agreement Tool or Form 9465.

6. Failing To Report Income

It’s easy to not claim all your tips or cash income, especially if you don’t track it consistently. But don’t get too comfy — failing to report all of your income to the IRS might count as tax fraud and evasion, or at least failure to supply information.

How to avoid it: Tipped employees should keep a daily record of all tips received and use Publication 531 to report their tip income. Even if you’re not a tipped employee, don’t fall victim to common misconceptions about hard-to-track income. Use the most recent version of Publication 525 to keep track of what the IRS considers taxable and nontaxable income.

Make Your Money Work For You

7. Falling Victim to Tax Preparer Fraud

In an IRS news release, Koskinen said it’s important to “choose your tax return preparer carefully, because you entrust them with your private financial information that needs to be protected.” Many U.S. taxpayers use tax professionals to prepare their returns. If you’re among this group, keep in mind that it’s always possible the preparers you rely on might dupe you into claiming credits or deductions you’re not entitled to in order to increase their own fees.

How to avoid it: When choosing a tax preparer, always confirm their IRS Preparer Tax Identification Number and professional credentials via the online IRS Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers with Credentials and Select Qualifications.

What Happens If You Commit Tax Fraud?

An individual who commits tax fraud can be fined up to $100,000 and sentenced to up to three years in prison. You might also be assessed a penalty of 75% of the amount you failed to pay due to fraud. The penalty for tax evasion is even steeper — up to $250,000 in fines and/or up to five years in prison. Willfully failing to file a return, pay taxes or keep or produce records can result in a fine of up to $25,000 and/or one year in jail.

How Do You Report Tax Fraud? Can You Report Someone to the IRS?

You can report suspected tax fraud using Form 3949-A, Information Referral. The form asks for information about the suspected fraudster and the violation you suspect they committed. You’ll also have to enter your own contact information, but the IRS won’t share it with the person or company you’re reporting. You can fill out the form online or mail the completed form to the address indicated:

Make Your Money Work For You

Internal Revenue Service PO Box 3801 Ogden, UT 84409

To report a tax return preparer for fraud or abusive practices, use Form 14157, Return Preparer Complaint.

What Is the Penalty for an Incorrect Tax Return?

The penalty for an honest mistake on your tax return is far less painful than the penalties for fraud and evasion. In the case of an error due to negligence, the IRS can charge you 20% of the amount you underpaid.

If you’re concerned about an issue with your taxes, it may help to reach out to professionals to assist you during an audit. Companies such as Tax Relief Advocates can examine your situation and help you navigate your next steps.

If you forget to include information or simply make a mistake on your tax return, it will typically take longer to process the return. It will also extend how long it takes to get your tax refund if you’re entitled to one. But keep in mind that omissions sometimes prompt the IRS to take a closer look at your forms and perhaps target you for tax fraud. Honesty and accuracy will keep you out of trouble with the IRS and ensure that you don’t pay out a cent more than you owe in tax.

Laura Beck and Gabrielle Olya contributed to the reporting for this article.

More From GOBankingRates


See Today's Best
Banking Offers