25 Member’s Mark Products Sam’s Club Shoppers Say Are Worth Every Penny

There are hundreds of Member’s Mark brand items to shop for at Sam’s Club. While nearly every item boasts positive reviews online and is priced low enough to save shoppers money, the standout buys, according to members, are largely grocery and household staples. 

GOBankingRates carefully reviewed hundreds of Member’s Mark products and pulled 25 based on their reviews and favorability with Sam’s Club members. Take a look at which items made the cut — and consider picking some up during your next shopping trip.

• Price: $12.18

Out of more than 19,000 reviews, Member’s Mark salted sweet cream butter has 90% five-star reviews. Members praise the taste and the quantity (four pounds in every package!) of this butter, with some shoppers remarking they’ve been buying it for 20 years.

• Price: $3.68

Shoppers get plenty of bang for their buck with Member’s Mark 2% reduced fat milk. Each gallon is priced at less than $4 and holds a 92% five-star review rating on the website — one of the highest we’ve seen out of any Member’s Mark product.

• Price: $6.58

Several flavors of Member’s Mark cheese rated high with Sam’s Club shoppers, but Member’s Mark colby and monterey Jack shredded cheese has one of the best overall ratings at 4.8.

Members receive two 16-ounce bags of cheese which melt and cook quickly in all your favorite dishes.

• Price: $8.92

Out of all the Member’s Mark frozen foods, the organic blueberries emerged as a fan favorite.

Each bag weighs in at three pounds. This comes out to spending about $2.97 per pound, which is typically cheaper than buying one pound of fresh blueberries at the supermarket.

• Price: $10.78

After surveying the snack aisle, we were surprised (in a good way) to see Member’s Mark fruity snacks emerge as one of Sam’s Club’s best buys. 

Positive reviews praise how everyone from kids to adults enjoys snacking on them. It also doesn’t hurt that you’re getting your money’s worth with 100 individually packaged bags in every box. 

• Price: $13.98

Out of the wide selection of Member’s Mark nuts available to shop, top honors went to the roasted whole cashews. These cashews are made with sea salt and come in a generously sized 33-ounce resealable container.

• Price: $18.98

What’s there to love about Member’s Mark Thai jasmine rice? 

According to shoppers, it’s easy to cook (and cooks evenly), tastes great and is inexpensive without compromising quantity at 25 pounds per bag. The only major complaint among shoppers is wishing the rice came in a 50-pound bag. 

• Price: $5.98

Give Member’s Mark olive oil cooking spray a chance, if you haven’t tried it already. This two-pack spray is praised by shoppers for how well it works, particularly in air fryers, and its reasonable price compared to individual sprays for sale at the supermarket.

• Price: $3.98

Put Member’s Mark sea salt to work seasoning your favorite recipes or curing meats to preserve them for longer. This salt has an overall 4.8 rating among members.

• Price: $7.98

We just mentioned salt, so now it’s time to highlight Member’s Mark fine ground black pepper. Ready to use from its 18-ounce canister, this black pepper has been complimented by shoppers for its taste and quantity.

• Price: $11.98

You can’t go wrong with Member’s Mark organic maple syrup. Top reviews from shoppers praise the syrup’s price for costing less than what you’d pay at a market and for the wholesome ingredients and taste.

• Price: $7.98

One of the highest-rated Member’s Mark items in the wine and spirits category is the Moscato D’Asti sparkling wine. At just under $8 per bottle, it receives its top marks thanks to its sweet, fruity flavor and taste to enjoy on its own or mixed in a mimosa.

• Price: $12.48

The next time you’re hosting a big party or get-together, make sure to buy Member’s Mark heavy-duty red cups. Each cup holds up to 18 ounces of your favorite beverage and comes with 240 cups packed inside every bag. 

• Price: $16.98

The holidays are right around the corner, so if you’re debating on which table pans to buy, try the full-size version from Member’s Mark. 

More than 3,000 shoppers have given these pans five-star ratings online and cite their durability for cooking, defrosting and storing meals as one of the best reasons to buy.

• Price: $16.89

Out of all the Member’s Mark trash bags to shop for, the Power Flex tall kitchen bags hold top honors with a 4.9 overall rating. Each box comes with 200 trash bags designed to hold up to 13 gallons worth of trash.

• Price: $17.48

Don’t pass up the Member’s Mark microfiber towels during your next shopping trip! These hidden gems come in a set of 36 towels and can be used to clean, dry and shine a variety of surfaces from cars to bathroom tiles. Currently, they have a 4.9 overall rating online.

• Price: $24.26

We’re not surprised to see Member’s Mark ultra toilet paper as the runaway favorite in the bulk paper products category. For less than $25, shoppers receive 45 rolls of two-ply premium toilet paper which comes out to about 54 cents per roll.

• Price: $18.98

The dinner paper plates from Member’s Mark routinely make appearances in our roundups thanks to their sturdiness, quantity (204 plates in every package) and price point. They’re just as beloved by shoppers and have a 4.9 overall rating.

• Price: $12.98

If you know and love the Member’s Mark dinner paper plates, you’re just as likely to be a fan of their soup and salad paper bowls. 

Like the plates, Sam’s Club members get a great value with this purchase. Every package comes with 150 bowls for just under $13.

• Price: $4.81

Member’s Mark men’s pique polos are selling out fast, so don’t wait for your chance to shop them in your preferred size and color while supplies last. 

Shoppers praise these shirts for being great to wear when golfing, traveling or biking thanks to their lightweight fit.

• Price: $14.98

Dress baby and save a little money when you shop for the three-pack set of Member’s Mark sleep and play apparel. 

Each set of jammies can be worn when snoozing or engaging in play with sizes ranging from newborn up to nine months. The sleepers have 92% of five-star reviews from Sam’s Club members with extra compliments going to how soft and breathable the material is and its double zippers.

• Price: $14.97

Swap out the more expensive allergy name brands for Member’s Mark allergy relief cetirizine hydrochloride tablets. 

This budget-friendly alternative comes with 400 tablets and holds a 4.9 overall rating from shoppers, many of which say it’s the best bargain on antihistamines around.

• Price: $13.86

Stockpile the medicine cabinet with Member’s Mark ibuprofen softgels. Shoppers who gave it a five-star rating highlight these over-the-counter (OTC) meds as a low-cost alternative for head and body ache relief and praise how well the aspirin works compared to name brands.

• Price: $13.47

Reduce fever and pains with the help of Member’s Mark extra-strength acetaminophen gelcaps. Each bottle comes with 400 gelcaps and holds a 4.9 rating, thanks to how fast they work and their value for the price.

• Price: $21.74

The Member’s Mark brand knows you can never have too many baby wipes when you have an infant. 

Their premium baby wipes not only come highly reviewed by Sam’s Club members, but they’re an unbelievable value with 12 packs in every box. The total wipe count for all 12 packages is 1,152 wipes, which comes out to spending two cents per wipe. 

Editor’s note: Prices and availability are accurate as of Aug. 27, 2025, and are subject to change.