Aldi vs. Trader Joe’s: Fans Debate Pros and Cons — Which Comes Out on Top?
Written by
Laura Adams
Edited by
Gary Dudak
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
While you might expect consumers to identify passionately with certain brands for items like clothes, automobiles and even electronics, one of the biggest fandoms to emerge among shoppers is actually for grocery stores.
Visit the Reddit forum dedicated to Aldi, and you’ll find people showing off their latest Aldi hauls — while also posting pictures of themselves, their babies, and their pets in branded Aldi merchandise. Not to be outdone, Trader Joe’s has its own share of dedicated fans, from TikTokers who share their hauls and recipes to throngs of people searching for special Trader Joe’s tote bags.
But in a head-to-head battle of these beloved stores, who has the edge? It depends on who you ask — and what you’re looking for.
For Pantry Staples, Aldi Is a Clear Winner
From foodies who love to cook to harried heads of household shopping for dinner, many people agree that Aldi is the better place to shop for essentials for the pantry, fridge and freezer. When the age-old debate of Aldi vs. Trader Joe’s was taken to Reddit, Redditors said that they preferred Aldi prices for the essentials.
“Maybe just where I live, but Trader Joe’s is way more expensive and is like a specialty store. Aldi is a bare bones lower cost for staples type store,” wrote one Redditor. Their comment received over 40 upvotes, with one fellow shopper responding, “A tweet I saw summed it up perfectly: Trader Joe’s is a food accessory store.”
But Aldi superfans aren’t the only ones who find that they can get the foundations for many a good meal at the store. In a piece for Business Insider, writer Joe Opaleski wanted to see what he could grab for his two-person household with only $20 in hand. He was surprised to find that he could supplement the items in his pantry quite well.
He loaded up on healthy staples like spinach and squash, ground chicken, granola and yogurt, while also finding crackers and grapes.
For Specialty Items, Trader Joe’s Comes Out on Top
From its store layouts to the names of its items, such as Trader Giotto’s for olive oil or the Joe’s O’s cereal, Trader Joe’s is known for being more creative than Aldi.
In the same thread comparing the two stores, Redditors said that they found a greater breadth and depth of options at Trader Joe’s — especially for frozen goods.
“In terms of frozen goods, I think TJ’s has way more variety and unique items. For example, was there last week and found 3-4 types of frozen Asian inspired chicken. Does my Aldi have that? Absolutely not,” wrote one Redditor. “Aldi seems to have less inventory and variety than the TJ’s I’ve been to.”
Trader Joe’s also comes with its own unique brands of nuts, oil, and coffee with flavors and prices that whet the appetite. When comparing Trader Joe’s and Aldi for CNET, writer Pamela Vachon quipped, “Trader Joe’s seems untouchable when it comes to discount prices on coffee, oils and nuts. (Who exactly is Joe trading with? The devil?).”
Vegan and vegetarian shoppers might also find more to enjoy at Trader Joe’s. Writing for Brit + Co, Chloe Williams found at least 23 distinct vegetarian meals available at Trader Joe’s. Vegan food influencer Conscious Chris has made many TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube posts (under the moniker Sweet Simple Vegan) about “lazy Trader Joe’s meals” that can satisfy vegans’ taste buds and their wallets alike.
So, Where Should You Shop?
Well, why not both? To get the best prices without forfeiting variety, you’d do well to get items from both places. Your pantry and your budget will thank you.
More From GOBankingRates
