7 Best Sam’s Club Thanksgiving Items To Buy for Less Than $25
Written by
Gabriel Vito
Edited by
Rebekah Evans
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
Thanksgiving is one of the most expensive meals of the year. Whether you’re hosting or bringing food to a party, prices can be steep. Between rising grocery prices and bigger guest lists, many shoppers are looking for cost-efficient grocery lists without cutting dishes from the table.
Luckily, Sam’s Club is still a go-to for stretching a holiday budget. The retailer offers oversized pies, ready-made sides, decor and hosting staples all for less than $25 per item, which can dramatically lower the cost of feeding a crowd. Below are the best sub-$25 options Sam’s Club typically carries this time of year, along with why they’re worth adding to your Thanksgiving shopping list.
Also here are Thanksgiving deals at Sam’s Club for under $10.
Member’s Mark Pumpkin Pie
- Price: $5.98
This oversized pie is one of Sam’s Club’s most iconic holiday items. It’s far larger than a standard grocery-store pumpkin pie and has exceptional price-per-slice value, perfect for feeding a big group.
Member’s Mark Mac and Cheese
- Price: $8.98
A simple, creamy mac and cheese that you can heat up in minutes. Nothing fancy, but it’s comforting, filling and easy to grab when you’re busy. The four-pack makes it an easy option to keep around for kids, workdays or late-night snacks.
Member’s Mark Yeast Rolls
- Price: $3.98
Dinner rolls disappear fast on Thanksgiving and this 24-count pack is one of the best bread values available. Soft, fluffy and bakery-quality, they’re ideal for dinner and next-day leftover sandwiches.
Member’s Mark Cheesy Potatoes
- Price: $9.88
This is one of those easy, throw-in-the-oven sides that make Thanksgiving less stressful. The cheesy potatoes come pre-sliced and layered with cheese and chives, so all you have to do is heat it until the top gets bubbly. It’s a simple, comforting dish that pairs well with turkey.
Turkey Gravy
- Price: $6.97
We can’t forget about the gravy. This two-pack is a simple way to make sure you actually have enough gravy on Thanksgiving. It tastes solid, heats up fast and does the job whether you’re pouring it over the turkey or using it on leftover sandwiches the next day.
Member’s Mark Cranberry Sauce
- Price: $7.97
This cranberry sauce has a straightforward, tangy flavor that works well with turkey, stuffing and all the usual Thanksgiving sides. The two-pack comes in resealable containers, so it’s easy to use for the main meal and still have some left for sandwiches the next day.
Thanksgiving-Themed Door Mat
- Price: $5.21
A Thanksgiving or autumn-themed doormat is a quick, inexpensive way to make your home feel welcoming as guests arrive. It’s a small touch, but it sets the tone the moment people walk in.
Tips for Saving Even More at Sam’s Club
Comparing per-unit prices can help you spot the best deals and avoid overbuying. Using Scan & Go speeds up your shopping trip, especially during peak holiday crowds. And stocking up early on freezer-friendly items like rolls, pies and prepared sides can help you avoid last-minute markups and sold-out shelves.
Editor’s note: Pricing and availability may vary depending on location.
More From GOBankingRates
