6 Pennies From the 1800s Worth a Lot of Money
Written by
Josephine Nesbit
Edited by
Cory Dudak
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
Over the past 167 years or so, when the U.S. Mint struck its first smaller-sized penny, there have been numerous varieties, errors, grades, mis-strikes, mint marks and more that have affected pricing in coin markets.
These 4 Rare Nickels From Over 20 Years Ago Are Worth a Ton Now
It’s rare to find older coins in good condition. If you’re lucky enough to find one that survived, some coin collectors may be willing to pay large sums of money to add it to their collection. Here are some of the most valuable pennies from the 1800s.
1856 1C Flying Eagle Penny
- Auction record: $172,500
The smaller penny wasn’t coined for circulation until 1857, but a few hundred proofs were coined for inspection by members of Congress a year earlier, according to the Numismatic Guaranty Company. The 1856 coin was minted in Philadelphia with an extremely low mintage of 634. CoinTrackers.com estimates a penny in average conditions to be worth $8,000, and one in mint state could be valued at $25,000.
1864 1C L on Ribbon, RD
- Auction record: $34,075
The 1864 Indian Head penny has an “L” on the ribbon behind the Indian Head and next to the bottom feather. A coin in good condition is worth $68, and uncirculated is around $519. According to USA Coin Book, a Proof coin can be worth $34,788 or more.
1871 1C, RD
- Auction record: $60,375
The 1871 Indian Head penny is part of a series of Indian Head, Shield Reverse coins struck between 1859 and 1909. A coin in average condition is worth around $60, while one in mint state could be as much as $875, according to CoinTrackers.com
1872 1C, RD
- Auction record: $126,500
The 1872 Indian Head penny is another valuable coin and part of the Indian Head, Shield Reverse series. The coin was minted in Philadelphia has no mint mark, and CoinTrackers.com estimates a coin in average condition to be worth around $80, while one in mint state could be worth as much as $1,350.
1873 1C Closed 3, RD
- Auction record: $54,625
You can distinguish the “Closed 3” variety by the 3 digit on the date, as it’s thicker than the Open 3 style. The ball serifs on the inner central part of the 3 digit are also closer to one another, which makes the 3 appear like an 8. A coin in average condition is only worth around $20, while one in mint state could be as much as $10,000, according to CoinTrackers.com. Proof coins are worth much more.
1888/7 1C, RB
Auction record: $72,000
The 1888 over 7 Indian Head penny is one of the most popular varieties in the Indian Cent series. The 8 digit was struck over a 7 digit on the date. You can see traces of the top portion of the 7 digit on the top left-hand portion of the last 8 digit. There’s also a small raised lump on the bottom of the 8. There are very few confirmed in uncirculated condition.
More From GOBankingRates
