7 Cars Middle-Class Retirees Should Avoid at All Costs
Written by
Laura Beck
Edited by
Molly Sullivan
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
Retirement should be about enjoying your golden years, not spending them at the repair shop or worrying about car payments. If you’re a middle-class retiree looking to buy a car, auto expert Chris Pyle from JustAnswer.com has some excellent advice to help you make a smart vehicle choice.
His first rule might surprise you: Forget about buying new cars entirely.
“In general, the middle-class income bracket should try to avoid buying any new car due to the cost and depreciation,” Pyle said. “As a retired person or couple, there is no need to waste your retirement income or make high monthly payments on an expensive car. Search for a used one.”
This advice becomes even more important when you consider that some cars are simply bad investments regardless of whether you buy them new or used. According to Pyle, certain vehicles should be completely avoided by retirees due to reliability issues, sky-high maintenance costs and terrible resale values. Due to these factors, here are seven cars to avoid.
Lincoln Nautilus
Lincoln markets the Nautilus as a luxury SUV, but Pyle said it’s anything but a smart choice for retirees.
“It is known for engine noise, some engine-related failures and it drops in value too fast,” he shared.
The combination of mechanical problems and rapid depreciation makes this SUV a double hit to your retirement budget. You’ll pay luxury prices upfront, then watch the value disappear while dealing with expensive repairs.
Cadillac Lyric
The Lyric represents Cadillac’s push into electric vehicles, but Pyle warned that all that advanced technology comes with serious downsides.
“Although this one is not known for parts failing, it is loaded with electronics that are expensive to replace when they do fail, and most of those electronics are tough to learn and figure out, even for the younger generation,” he said. “Also, like the Lincoln, fast depreciation.”
For retirees who want reliable transportation without having to become tech experts, the Lyric’s complex systems can be overwhelming and costly to maintain.
Jeep Wrangler
While some retirees might be tempted by the Wrangler’s off-road capabilities, Pyle strongly advised against it.
“Although not really a retiree vehicle, there may be some who want to go off the beaten path to enjoy nature. Think twice on this ride,” he said. “It is plagued with basically everything outside the cab failing, except the paint.”
The constant repairs mean you’ll spend more time with mechanics than enjoying the outdoors. For retirees wanting to explore nature, Pyle suggested looking elsewhere.
Jeep Grand Cherokee
If you thought the larger Grand Cherokee might be better, think again. Pyle said it has all the Wrangler’s problems plus additional electronic headaches.
“The Jeep Grand Cherokee has mostly identical issues, but add in electronics failing to that list on this one,” he explained. “You will spend more time in the shop and less time enjoying retirement.”
Both Jeep models share the same fundamental problem: They’re designed for ruggedness but deliver unreliability instead.
Volkswagen Jetta
The Jetta might seem like a practical compact car choice, but Pyle pointed out some big issues for retirees.
“Common brake-related issues and concerns with the climate control. Plus, it is not easy to find shops outside of VW to work on them,” he said.
Having limited repair options can be especially problematic for retirees who travel or live in areas without nearby Volkswagen dealerships. When something breaks, you’re stuck with expensive dealer service.
Mitsubishi Mirage
While the Mirage wins awards for affordability, Pyle said it’s a terrible choice for anyone who values comfort.
“You will find your old joints are going to hate you after 30 minutes in this car,” he shared. “It excels in a cheap basic car, but not good for a retired person to travel in.”
For retirees who might want to take road trips or spend extended time driving, comfort becomes crucial. The Mirage’s rock-bottom price comes at the cost of basic comfort features that matter more as we age.
Kia Cadenza
The Cadenza represents a particularly frustrating category: cars that promise luxury but don’t deliver value.
“It has a semi-luxury price but subpar in luxury. Although it is a dependable car, you are just not getting what you hoped for,” Pyle said.
While reliability isn’t the issue here, value is. Retirees paying luxury prices deserve luxury features and comfort, not just the appearance of them.
The Common Threads
Looking at Pyle’s list, several patterns emerge that retirees should watch for when car shopping:
Rapid depreciation: Several of these vehicles lose value quickly, meaning your investment disappears faster than it should.
Complex electronics: Modern luxury features often mean expensive repair bills when things go wrong.
Limited service options: Some brands require specialized service that can be hard to find and expensive to obtain.
Poor comfort: For people who may have mobility issues or spend lots of time driving, comfort features become necessities, not luxuries.
The Smart Retiree Strategy
Instead of falling for these somewhat problematic vehicles, Pyle’s advice centers on practical wisdom: Buy used, focus on reliability and avoid the temptation of unnecessary luxury features that will cost you later.
If you’re on a fixed income, you just need transportation you can count on without endangering your retirement budget. The goal isn’t to have the fanciest car in the neighborhood — it’s to have reliable transportation that lets you enjoy retirement instead of worrying about repair bills.
More From GOBankingRates
