5 Must-Try Christmas Desserts at Sam’s Club To Grab Before They’re Gone

Don Shreve / Walmart

Commitment to Our Readers

GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.

20 Years
Helping You Live Richer

Reviewed
by Experts

Trusted by
Millions of Readers

If you’re craving Christmas sweets but don’t want to spend hours baking, it might be time to check out the bakery at Sam’s Club. They have all sorts of desserts that sell out fast and are perfect for Christmas dinner tables and holiday parties.

Browse the selection of delicious Sam’s Club treats below and be sure to pick up enough for you’re holiday gathering; it’s entirely possible you won’t have another chance before they disappear from shelves.

1. Member’s Mark Cookie Dough Brownies

• Price: $9.98

Member’s Mark cookie dough brownies are soft, gooey and chocolatey — perfect when you pair them with coffee or a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

“These are tasty, but then I read to try them heated up prior to eating. And boy oh boy, it was tastier!” one happy customer said on the retailer’s website. “Substituting milk for my normal tea took me back to my childhood, eating warm brownies just out of the oven. Sure did enjoy these!”

2. Member’s Mark Chocolate Yule Log Cake

• Price: $15.97

For the unfamiliar, a chocolate Yule log is a rolled sponge cake filled with buttercream, covered in rich chocolate frosting and decorated to look like a traditional Yule log. It serves around ten people, which makes it great for family dinners or holiday gatherings.

“This Yule Log was AMAZING!! We went back to get another and they were all sold out, well before Christmas,” a satisfied customer named Pam Lake warned. “This needs to be made and stocked for longer next year. The cake and filling were wonderful, and the outer coating was perfect!”

3. Member’s Mark Cheesecake Minis

• Price: $18.27

Member’s Mark cheesecake minis are bite-sized, individually wrapped mini-cheesecakes that thaw in the fridge and are ready to serve. For just under $20, you get 63 cheesecake minis of three different flavors, including New York Style, Caramel Chocolate Chip and Strawberry Swirl.

“I bought these for a family dinner and everyone raved about how good they were, especially the chocolate chip caramel ones,” noted yet another satisfied customer. “I thought they all were fantastic. They thawed within minutes and were just the right size that we each could try a flavor.”

4. Member’s Mark Chocolate Overload Cake

• Price: $18.97

The Member’s Mark Chocolate Overload Cake is a 10-inch chocolate cake that is baked fresh, layered with whipped chocolate mousse, studded with brownie and cookie pieces, then topped with chocolate syrup and white chocolate curls. It serves 12 to 16 people, which is perfect if you’re hosting a crowd that appreciates bold chocolate desserts.

5. Member’s Mark Assorted Cookie Tray

• Price: $19.93

This Member’s Mark assorted cookie tray comes with 84 cookies in several flavors, including chocolate chunk, oatmeal raisin, white-chunk macadamia and mini candy. Plus, it contains no trans fat or high fructose corn syrup, which makes it a slightly healthier alternative than some other cookies.

One happy customer explained: “I had volunteered to provide cookies for a school event. The original plan was to make them myself. However, there was a large adjustment in quantity at the last minute. Sam’s saved me, the cookies are a nice variety, taste great and are reasonably priced.”

Disclaimer: Prices and availability accurate as of Dec. 23, 2025 and subject to change. All imagery sourced from SamsClub.com.

Share This Article: