I’m 67: Here’s the Exact Script I Used To Cut My Car Insurance by $624 Annually
Written by
Laura Beck
Edited by
Rebekah Evans
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
Cheryl B. is 67 years old and had been with USAA for a decade.
She hadn’t renegotiated her car insurance once in those 10 years. When she finally made the call, she cut her annual premium by $624 using a simple script. Below is how she did it.
Also here are other insurance policies you may be overpaying.
The Script She Used
Cheryl walked us through exactly what she did. First, she called USAA and opened with a friendly but direct approach. “Hi, I’ve been a USAA member for about 10 years and I really appreciate the service. I’m calling because I haven’t reviewed my auto policy in a long time and I’d like to lower my premium if possible,” she said.
She paused and let them respond. Then she signaled she was shopping around without making threats of switching providers: “I’m planning to compare rates this week, but I wanted to check with you first to see if there are any discounts, adjustments or loyalty credits available before I look elsewhere.”
This told USAA three things. She was serious about saving money, she was price-sensitive and she was still giving them first chance to keep her business.
Asking for Specific Cuts
After the representative reviewed her policy, she had them check specific discounts by saying: “Can you check whether I qualify for low-mileage discount, defensive driving discount, safe driver or accident-free discount, bundling discount or any loyalty pricing review?”
The Mileage Change Made a Difference
Cheryl’s biggest savings came from updating her mileage. She told them: “I’m not commuting daily anymore. My annual mileage is approximately 6,000 miles. Can you re-rate my policy based on current usage?”
That single change dropped her premium significantly. Most policies assume higher mileage unless you specifically request an adjustment.
Reviewing Coverage Line by Line
Cheryl asked: “Is there anything on this policy that most members in my situation typically reduce or remove?”
The representative found rental car coverage she never used. Her old policy had a $500 deductible when she was comfortable with $1,000. She also had medical payment coverage that duplicated her Medicare.
When she asked “If I increased my deductible from $500 to $1,000, how much would that lower my premium?” the answer was $156 per year.
The Comparison Quote Strategy
Before calling USAA, Cheryl got two comparison quotes online. When the representative finished reviewing her policy, she said: “I received a quote for $987 annually with similar coverage. Is there any way you can get closer to that?”
The representative found additional adjustments that brought her premium down further.
What She Actually Saved
Cheryl’s annual premium dropped from $1,812 to $1,188. That’s $624 per year or $52 per month. The savings came from four changes: updating her mileage for a $228 annual reduction, raising her deductible for $156 in savings, removing rental coverage for $120 saved and applying a safe driver discount for $120 off.
Cheryl’s advice to other seniors is simple: Call once a year and ask these exact questions. Your mileage changes, your deductible tolerance changes and new discounts appear. None of that happens automatically.
More From GOBankingRates
