Protect Yourself From These 5 Zelle Scams in 2023

fizkes / iStock.com

Zelle is a popular way of sending money straight from your bank account to another U.S. bank or credit union account in just minutes. All that is needed to transfer money is a mobile phone number or email address. An even better feature, Zelle doesn’t charge a fee. Zelle users enjoy the convenience of its peer-to-peer payment service, but be aware that with this convenience comes the risk of fraudulent scheming. 

5 Zelle Scams To Avoid

Despite Zelle’s safeguards, scams can occur, and as a consumer, you should watch for suspicious activities like these five common scams:

1. The puppy scam
2. The text or email from your bank scam
3. The fraud department scam
4. The utility company scam
5. The fake job scam

Keep reading to learn more about these scams and how to avoid them.

1. The Puppy Scam

Bad news: there’s no puppy. During the pandemic, a woman decided a dog could boost the spirits of her family and fell in love with “Lilly,” a puppy she saw advertised online. It turns out there was no Lilly, which she learned after sending almost $4,000 via Zelle in a series of payments that she thought were for the dog, a pressurized crate and insurance, consumer group Elliott Advocacy shared.

How To Protect Yourself

The fake puppy — or other fake pet — is a common scam. Don’t send money to anyone without first meeting the pet in person — or at least use a payment method with purchase protection, like a credit card.

2. The Text or Email From Your Bank Scam

A scam could start with a text popping up on your mobile phone, purportedly by your bank seeking to confirm that you made a specific transaction and asking you to respond “yes” or “no” about whether it’s legitimate. For example, you get a text from Capital One asking for this response.

“Most Zelle scams are rather simplistic: You might receive a text about a transfer of money that you, quite obviously, did not authorize,” said Monica Eaton-Cardone, the founder of Chargebacks911, which helps to combat fraud. “The scammer waits for you to respond, poses as a representative of your bank, and then tricks you into disclosing enough personal and financial information to successfully transfer your funds.”

How To Protect Yourself

Experts recommend never clicking a link in a text message or email. Call your bank directly instead to determine whether your bank account has been compromised.

3. The Fraud Department Scam

A New Jersey woman shared with NJ.com how she was scammed out of $1,000 when she received a call from someone who claimed to be from her bank’s fraud prevention department questioning a pending transaction. A call can look and sound legitimate, even down to your caller ID showing a genuine contact name and number for your financial institution.

“He said in order to stop the charge before it went through, I would have to access my PNC Zelle app to reverse the unauthorized transaction,” she said. “He gave me a code to enter, and he told me to enter my first and last name and type ‘reversal’ on the Zelle memo.”

Despite her suspicions, she did it. And lost her money.

How To Protect Yourself

Never provide personal information or follow the instructions of someone who calls you — instead, call your bank directly so you know for sure who you’re talking to.

4. The Utility Company Scam

In April 2022, a woman living in a Cleveland suburb shared her Zelle scam story with a local television station, describing the call she received from her purported utility company that said she had 30 minutes to pay her bill before her power would be cut off. The man she spoke with knew the details of her account — including her address and the balance due — and told her to send the money via Zelle.

She told News5 in Cleveland that the caller instructed her how to transfer the amount due, $295.64, but the first attempt encountered a glitch. So did the second and third tries, she was told, and then he gave her a security code for the fourth effort. Money was deducted all four times, with almost $1,200 going to the scammer’s account and not the utility company’s.

How To Protect Yourself

Only make payments to your utility company — or any other bills — directly to your provider, through your account.

5. The Fake Job Scam

A California woman told ABC7 television in San Francisco that she was delighted to find a new work-from-home job with a reputable healthcare company that would allow her to continue to care for her aging parents. Her hiring manager sent her a $1,900 check to buy computer equipment she needed, and once she deposited the check, she was to pay for the gear by sending the money to two Zelle contacts provided.

She did, but it turns out the person wasn’t a hiring manager, there wasn’t a job with the company, the check bounced and she overdrew her account. She didn’t receive any equipment and became another victim of a Zelle scam.

How To Protect Yourself

No matter how good it sounds, a job that requires you to pay anything from your own account with your own debit card — even if they send a check to cover it — to get started is probably fake. Best to move on to another opportunity. You can also research the job and employer. If the job is on a third-party site but not listed on the company site, it probably doesn’t exist.

Can You Get Money Back From Zelle if Scammed?

According to Early Warning Services, if someone accesses your account and conducts a Zelle transaction without your knowledge, that’s a fraud. Because you didn’t authorize the activity, you should get your money back.

However, if you are aware of the transaction and authorized a payment to be sent, that’s a scam. And the company says that even though you’re a victim who was tricked, you’re probably out of luck when it comes to getting your money back because you gave the okay.

Tips on Avoiding Zelle Scams

You might think the threat of a scam is a reason why you should not use Zelle, but it can be used safely if you watch for red flags. Ben Alvarado, the executive vice president and director of core banking at California Bank & Trust, offered these tips to avoid being a victim of a scam.

• Be wary of a phone call: “Cybercriminals will often call consumers and act as banking professionals in order to trick them into giving up their personal information, such as a log-in ID and password,” he said. “It’s vital to understand that banks will never call consumers, especially when it comes to accessing personal information.”

• Only send money to people you know: “Payment apps were created to easily send money to friends, family and the people you know, not to buy products or services,” Alvarado said. “If you see an advertisement that promotes a product but then requires you to send money through a payment app, it is likely a scam.”

• Maximize your safety settings: “Enabling multifactor authentication is a surefire way to safeguard your personal information and protect yourself from frauds and scams. Most popular payment apps include this security feature, which requires a second or even third step to verify your account when you log onto a new or existing device.”

Final Take

Using Zelle is a convenient way to send money to people you know. But think twice about sending funds to people you’ve never met or to people who contact you demanding payment. Banking apps and payment apps should serve you and protect your information. Take all precautions to keep yourself from falling victim to a scam.

Caitlyn Moorhead contributed to the reporting for this article.

Editorial Note: This content is not provided by any entity covered in this article. Any opinions, analyses, reviews, ratings or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the author alone and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any entity named in this article.

Share This Article: