4 European Cars Retirees Should Avoid, Plus the Best European Cars To Own on Social Security
Written by
Laura Beck
Edited by
Molly Sullivan
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
Chris Pyle, a mechanic who consults with vehicle owners on JustAnswer, doesn’t mince words about European cars and Social Security budgets: They don’t mix.
“I cannot imagine a retired person, or couple, or someone living off Social Security purchasing a new European car,” Pyle said. His reasoning goes beyond simple purchase price. The entire ownership experience creates financial traps that fixed-income retirees can’t afford.
Why European Cars Wreck Retirement Budgets
European brands include Volkswagen, Audi, BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Porsche and Fiat. Most models start at price points that immediately eliminate them for those with conservative budgets.
But even if you find an affordable used European car, Pyle warned the real costs come later. “Maintenance costs are high, repairs are expensive and major repairs are the cost of a good used car,” he explained.
That last point deserves emphasis. A transmission or engine repair on a BMW or Mercedes can be costly. You’re essentially gambling one functional car against keeping a problematic European model running.
The Dealer Problem Nobody Talks About
American brands like Ford and Chevrolet have dealerships everywhere. European brands don’t.
“They are not like Ford and Chevy, where there is a dealer in each town,” Pyle said. “You may have to drive 100+ miles to find a European dealer to work on your car.”
For retirees, that creates a logistical nightmare. Most independent mechanics refuse European cars because the diagnostic equipment and specialized knowledge required aren’t worth the investment for the small number of customers who own them. That forces European car owners to dealerships that charge premium labor rates.
The distance problem compounds when repairs take time. “Then you have the hassle of getting back home and returning days or weeks later once repaired,” Pyle explained. Arranging rides, renting cars or waiting around in an unfamiliar city eats up time and money retirees don’t have.
Cars To Avoid Completely
Pyle’s advice is blunt: “I would advise my own parents to look elsewhere and pass on all of these brands.”
When a mechanic who sees thousands of repair cases tells you he’d steer his own parents away from entire categories of vehicles, that’s worth listening to.
BMW – Luxury German engineering comes with luxury repair bills. Parts cost multiples of what domestic brands charge, and complex electronics mean expensive diagnostic time before mechanics even start fixing problems.
Mercedes-Benz – Mercedes reliability declined significantly over the past two decades. Repair costs rival BMW.
Porsche – Sports car engineering means sports car maintenance costs. Even Porsche’s SUV models require premium fuel, specialized service and parts that cost double or triple what mainstream brands charge.
Fiat – Fiat returned to the American market with small, affordable vehicles. But reliability problems emerged quickly, and the dealer network remains sparse. You get European repair headaches without even getting luxury features.
The Least-Bad Options (If You Insist)
“If you are dead set on European on a budget, then Audi and VW would be the better options,” Pyle said. He offered specific model recommendations with a major caveat.
Volkswagen Atlas and Tiguan – These VW SUVs represent the most practical European choices for retirees who refuse to consider other brands. They cost less than German luxury brands and VW’s dealer network is slightly more widespread.
Audi A3, A4 and Q3 – Audi shares components with Volkswagen, which helps keep costs somewhat lower than BMW or Mercedes. The A3 and A4 sedans plus the Q3 compact SUV offer entry points into German brands without the highest-tier pricing.
But Pyle immediately undercut even these recommendations. “I would love to say, though, that I get good reviews from owners. I know so few who purchase these brands. I do not get a true first-hand experience.”
Translation: So few people on budgets buy these vehicles that he can’t confidently vouch for them based on real-world ownership experiences. He’s naming them only because they’re marginally less problematic than other European options.
What Retirees Should Do Instead
“Retired people should be focusing more on the cost of ownership and the hassle of getting repairs done,” Pyle emphasized. European cars fail on both measures.
Total cost of ownership includes purchase price, insurance, fuel, routine maintenance, unexpected repairs and depreciation. European cars score poorly across most categories. Insurance costs more because parts cost more. Many require premium fuel. Maintenance intervals might be longer, but each service visit costs significantly more than domestic or Japanese brands. Repairs devastate budgets when they happen.
The hassle factor matters more as you age. Dealing with a broken car is stressful at any age, but becomes harder when you’re managing health issues, limited mobility or cognitive decline. According to Pyle, European cars force you into dealer-only service networks that may be hours away from your home.
More From GOBankingRates
