PayPal Stock (PYPL): Is It a Good Buy?

San Jose, USA - October 15, 2015: PayPal headquarters located at 2221 N.
Jason Doiy / Getty Images

Established in 2000, PayPal provided a payments hub for the online auction site eBay, which bought the company outright in 2002. In 2015, eBay spun off PayPal as an independent operation that has since become the world’s largest online money transfer business. PayPal remained an important component of eBay until 2021 when the auction site began paying sellers directly rather than through the PayPal platform.

About PayPal and Features

Along with its subsidiaries Venmo and Xoom, PayPal offers web and mobile platforms. Customers can pay for goods, send and exchange money, and borrow. Through PayPal Credit, the company allows customers to access lines of credit.

A crypto platform enables members to buy Bitcoin, Ethereum and other virtual currencies and use these virtual assets for purchases. For a fee, the platform converts crypto into equivalent currency at the time of sale.

The growth of “buy now, pay later” online retailing has provided PayPal with another revenue boost. In this type of transaction, a customer can delay payment on a purchased item over several months or a year. PayPal asks the seller for a small discount on the purchase price and pockets the difference when the buyer eventually completes the payment.

Building Wealth

Pandemic Posed No Problem for PayPal

These in-demand money services have brought the company solid growth in revenues and net earnings over the past decade. PayPal stock had already been a hot item for institutional and individual investors for several years at the start of the pandemic year of 2020, when lockdowns and shortages drove many shoppers to online retail platforms.

In that year, COVID-19 restrictions on in-person shopping provided a major boost to traffic on PayPal and its subsidiaries. Earnings growth reached a heady 71% in the fiscal year 2020, more than tripling the 19% growth rate of 2019.

The second quarter of 2021 saw a major boost to payment volume, which climbed 36% year over year to $311 billion, while new active accounts from 2020 to 2021 fell 47% to 11.4 million. Net revenue in the second quarter of 2021 rose 17% to $6.24 billion, and earnings per share reached $1.

Service Innovations

PayPal has been leading the financial sector in digital innovations since 2020. The company revamped and updated its platform in the fall of 2021 with a host of new capabilities. Customers now have automatic bill pay and high-yield savings accounts available, as well as two-day early direct deposit access. Online shoppers have a range of new in-app tools at hand, including:

Building Wealth
  • Cash redeemable rewards
  • Gift cards
  • Charitable giving
  • PayPal shopping credit
  • Instant access to merchant discounts

The company introduced a paper check-cashing feature to Venmo members in the U.S. and launched touch-free QR payments for small businesses through its Europe-based Zettle. Xoom, PayPal’s money transfer subsidiary, has expanded services to 12 markets in Africa.

PayPal’s Trading Platform

PayPal is also developing a trading platform for stock market investors, a response to the phenomenal growth of trading platforms offered by Square, SoFi, E-Trade and Robinhood. Having been the first to the online auction business, PayPal doesn’t want to miss the trend of individual investors drawn to the markets by the “gamification” of trading on commission-free Robinhood and the gains shown by markets post-COVID-19.

Although building a new trading platform would face regulatory hurdles, PayPal has a big advantage in the form of an enormous 400-million-plus established customer base.

Competition

With these new services, however, PayPal is running hard just to keep up. The fee-driven online money transfer business has attracted big banks as well as competition from established European companies seeking a foothold in the U.S.

In October 2021, U.K.-based SumUp, a point-of-sale card reader business, purchased Fivestars, a San Francisco-based digital marketing company. The new company will directly compete with Square, a similar U.S.-based business, but it also poses a market share threat to PayPal.

PayPal’s Security Risks

PayPal is also susceptible to the digital scourge of hacked accounts, stolen identities and mysteriously missing funds. The app enjoys a reputation for security, and PayPal has avoided major negative publicity over customer privacy issues. But hacked PayPal accounts are available on the dark web, for a fee, and one IT investigator has found that the value of these accounts nearly tripled during the pandemic.

“Cloud outages” and technical difficulties also pose a danger to wider acceptance of online money services. In case of any issues, PayPal customers must get in line with others for the dreaded customer service call. Amid these unpredictable IT problems and the constant drumbeat of hacking stories associated with credit cards, banks and retailers may put a lid on the future growth of PayPal and its competitors.

P/E and Earnings Trends

PayPal stock has been an institutional favorite for several years, and investors considering a move into the shares may want to consider the possibility that rapid future growth is already priced into the shares. The return to in-person shopping post-COVID may also blunt the phenomenal growth rate the company enjoyed in 2020, leading to unimpressive year-over-year comparisons.

By October 2021, PayPal had reached a high valuation, at a price-to-earnings ratio of about 65. This represents a premium over the market average, but in the mid-range for the company over the past five years. Price-to-earnings has been slipping downward since hitting 100-plus in 2020.

Earnings comparisons over the next few quarters may also reflect PayPal’s exit from the eBay platform in 2021. The separation of the two companies was amicable, and long-term investors such as hedge fund Wedgewood were not deterred.

“We continue to hold PayPal as a core position,” Wedgewood declared in its third quarterly newsletter, “and think eBay represents short-term noise in PayPal’s longer-term drive to become a ‘super all’ with payments at its core.”

Is PayPal Stock a Good Buy?

PayPal has grown into a formidable, reliable and innovative operation since its start with eBay. It also has global brand recognition and acceptance going for it.

Innovation doesn’t always translate into growth, however, and those pondering a new investment in the company may want to consider what the principle of “creative destruction” might mean for online platforms such as PayPal.

Cryptocurrencies, for example, remove financial transactions from the control of institutions, banks and money transfer companies and move them to individual savers, buyers and merchants. With the widespread use of digital wallets, will the masses really need an online, fee-based money transfer business?

Good To Know

PayPal has been a reliable innovator, meeting the market’s expectations with a series of new features, services and capabilities. Always searching for new paradigms, investors have also been attracted by PayPal’s status as a leading “neo bank” that directly challenges institutions such as JPMorgan, Wells Fargo and Bank of America.

Our in-house research team and on-site financial experts work together to create content that’s accurate, impartial, and up to date. We fact-check every single statistic, quote and fact using trusted primary resources to make sure the information we provide is correct. You can learn more about GOBankingRates’ processes and standards in our editorial policy.

About the Author

​​A writer and editor with more than 100 book credits in the juvenile and young adult non-fiction format, Tom Streissguth has mastered the craft of explaining complex, difficult subjects clearly. His books have covered history, geography, economics, media and current affairs; he's also written biographies of historical figures for Lerner, Enslow, Facts on File, Greenhaven and other major educational publishers.

Untitled design (1)
Close popup The GBR Closer icon

Sending you timely financial stories that you can bank on.

Sign up for our daily newsletter for the latest financial news and trending topics.

Loading...
Please enter an email.
Please enter a valid email address.
There was an unknown error. Please try again later.

For our full Privacy Policy, click here.