Walmart and Target Are Competing With Dollar Stores — Where Are the Best Deals?

Commitment to Our Readers

GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.

20 Years
Helping You Live Richer

Reviewed
by Experts

Trusted by
Millions of Readers

It used to be that you could bet your bottom dollar that discount retailers like Dollar General or Dollar Tree would have the best deals for basics like grocery staples or house decor. However, in recent years, the battle for budget-conscious shoppers has intensified, with Walmart and Target increasingly competing with dollar stores for dominance in the low-price retail space. With inflation squeezing wallets, consumers like you have more options than before.

So, where are the best deals? In most circumstances, it all depends on just what’s on your shopping list. 

Walmart vs. Dollar Tree: The One-Stop Bargain Hub

Walmart, one of the world’s largest retailers, has always focused on offering everyday low prices. In recent years, Walmart has sharpened its focus on essential goods, from groceries to household items, with a heavy emphasis on cost-saving strategies.

With its massive buying power, Walmart can negotiate lower prices with suppliers, which often results in savings passed directly to the consumer. However, Dollar Tree has numerous grocery items and cleaning supplies all for about $1.25.

Grocery Deals

Walmart’s grocery section is a stronghold for those looking to save on their weekly food budget. Its private-label brand, Great Value, often matches or undercuts the prices of similar products found at dollar stores. Bulk items like canned goods, pasta and rice frequently offer lower per unit prices, especially if you shop smart and keep an eye on promotions or use Walmart’s app to find exclusive discounts.

Target vs. Dollar General: Stylizing Your Savings

Target, known for its trendy style and quality goods, is a great way to budget shop without looking like you did, but its private-label brands have helped it compete fiercely with dollar stores in the essentials category. Dollar General also always has an array of ever-evolving, cheap but cheerful decorations. When you’re updating your seasonal decor, both Target and Dollar General pull out all the stops.

Home Decor and Seasonal Decorations

Target’s Up & Up brand is a strong contender when it comes to cleaning products, toiletries and decoration essentials. While its prices may be slightly higher than those at dollar stores, Target frequently offers promotions like a $5 gift card when you spend $20 on select household goods, which is great when you are spicing up your decor for the fall or holiday season. 

Dollar General also carries a variety of themed candles, throw pillows and more to help welcome holidays to your home. Most items cost between $1 to $5, which puts dollars stores at a lower price point than Target on average but Target does fire back with the Bulleye’s Playground and the Dollar Spot, which puts it in a tight foot race with dollar stores. 

Big Ticket Items vs. Everyday Small Purchases

Dollar stores like Dollar General, Dollar Tree and Family Dollar have built their reputations on ultra-low prices for everyday items. These stores typically had a stronghold on niche retail because it was the combination of value and convenience, but now those numbers are dropping in large part because of big-name competitors trying to do the same thing. Now that mega-retailers like Walmart and Target are entering the dollar section arena, it may help to break down deals by items on your shopping list. 

Smaller Prices

While dollar stores do offer unbeatable prices on smaller packages of snacks, canned goods and pantry staples, it’s important to note that you’re often paying more per ounce or per unit compared to Walmart or Target. These stores cater to those looking to spend less in the moment, but over time, bulk purchases from larger retailers might be more economical.

Bigger Stock

When it comes to household products like paper towels, soap and trash bags, dollar stores tend to offer a narrower selection, and the quality is often inferior to what you’d find at Walmart or Target. While the price may be right for quick or small purchases, if you’re buying in bulk or seeking higher-quality items, Walmart and Target typically offer a better deal in the long run.

Convenience Factor

The big draw of dollar stores remains convenience. With smaller store footprints and locations often in rural or underserved areas, they offer quick, no-frills shopping experiences for those looking to grab a few essentials without the need for a larger shopping trip.

Final Take To GO: Where Are the Best Deals?

The bottom line is that when you are looking for the best deal, it depends on what you’re buying and how much you’re purchasing. It may help to look at your shopping habits based on your weekly or monthly budget and go from there. Here are some areas where deals can differ:

• For bulk groceries and household essentials, Walmart tends to come out on top. Its extensive inventory, competitive prices and ability to offer large quantities for less make it the best choice for stocking up.
• If you’re looking for home products with added perks, Target provides the best value, especially if you’re a Target Circle or RedCard member, thanks to the extra discounts and gift card promotions.
• For small, quick purchases, dollar stores are still the kings. Their rock-bottom prices on single items are tough to beat when you’re in a pinch and need to spend as little as possible on fewer items.

In today’s competitive retail environment, Walmart, Target and dollar stores each have their own strengths, and savvy shoppers can maximize savings by knowing where and when to shop. For those keeping a close eye on their wallets, it’s all about finding the right balance between price, quality and convenience.

Share This Article: