What Is a Stimulus Check? How It Works, Pros and Cons, and the Future Outlook

PrathanChorruangsak / Getty Images/iStockphoto

Commitment to Our Readers

GOBankingRates' editorial team is committed to bringing you unbiased reviews and information. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and services - our reviews and ratings are not influenced by advertisers. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and our products and services review methodology.

20 Years
Helping You Live Richer

Reviewed
by Experts

Trusted by
Millions of Readers

Stimulus checks issued by the government as a way to stimulate the economy, especially in a downturn. Its purpose is to help people spend more, boosting the economy.

Here’s more about how they work, the benefits available to you, as well as any drawbacks, and how they might be used going forward.

See: What To Do if You Owe Back Taxes to the IRS

Key Takeaways

• What they are: Government-issued payments to citizens to stimulate the economy.
• How they work: Stimulus checks are distributed during economic downturns to encourage consumer spending.
• Primary advantage: Stimulus checks provide immediate relief, boost consumer spending and have a multiplying effect on the economy.
• Main disadvantage: Could lead to increased national debt, potential issues with targeting, and are a short-term fix.
• Future outlook: Dependent on economic trends, governnment policy and a lookback on how effective they’ve been in the past.

What Is a Stimulus Check?

A stimulus check provides direct payments to taxpayers and are issued by the U.S. government. It’s typically issued during times of economic hardship, such as recessions or global crises, with the primary goal of reviving economic activity.

The theory behind these checks is straightforward: by providing people with extra funds, their spending power increases, which in turn can lead to higher demand for goods and services, create more jobs for people, and thus, stimulate overall economic growth.

Stimulus Checks and the Multiplying Effect

Here’s the idea behind the multiplying effect: When people spend stimulus checks, that money flows into the economy, setting off a chain reaction. For instance, your spending at a local store transfers that money to the business, enabling them to pay their staff. These employees, in turn, use their earnings for their expenses, starting a cycle of spending.

Continuously moving the money create a ripple effect of economic activity, and may end up being worth more than the initial check that was given. Stimulus checks do more than just assist those who receive them; they can help affect broader economic growth.

How Do Stimulus Checks Work?

Issuing stimulus checks involves a multiple steps. First, the government must approve the bill that will be sent to taxpayers. Next, the treasury or relevant government department distributes the funds. This is typically done by sending checks or direct deposit.

Whether or not you receive a stimulus check might be based on factors such as income levels, tax bracket, or employment status, as examples. The objective is to ensure that the money reaches those who are likely to spend it quickly, thus stimulating economic activity.

What Are the Benefits of Stimulus Checks?

Stimulus checks can offer several benefits. These include:

• Immediate financial support: One of the most significant advantages of stimulus checks is their ability to provide rapid financial assistance.
• Boost in consumer spending: By increasing the household disposable income, these checks encourage spending, thereby directly benefiting businesses, particularly in the retail and service sectors.
• Wider economic impact: The increase in consumer spending can have a domino effect, and have a positive impact on the economy. This includes increased demand for goods, which can lead to more production and potentially more jobs.
• Psychological benefits: Beyond the financial aspect, stimulus checks can offer a psychological boost to consumers, enhancing their confidence in the economy.
• Assistance during unprecedented times: In extraordinary circumstances, like the COVID-19 pandemic, stimulus checks have played a central role in providing emergency support to millions who faced unemployment or reduced income.

Challenges and Criticisms of Stimulus Checks

While stimulus checks have clear benefits, they also present several challenges. These include:

• Increased national debt: Funding for stimulus checks often leads to increased government borrowing, contributing to higher national debt, which can have long-term economic consequences.
• Stimulus check recipients: There’s a debate about the efficiency of stimulus checks in reaching the most affected individuals. In some cases, funds may go to those less likely to spend them, reducing the overall impact on the economy.
• Short-term nature: While effective as an immediate response, stimulus checks are not a solution to deeper economic issues, such as unemployment or stock market ups and downs.
• Inflationary pressures: Sending extra money into the economy could drive inflation, particularly if the increase in consumer spending outpaces the production of goods and services.

Expert Opinions and Economic Analyses

Economists and financial experts often have varied opinions on the use of stimulus checks. Some advocate for their effectiveness in emergency situations, while others caution against their overuse, particularly highlighting concerns related to national debt and inflation.

Public Perception and Impact on Consumer Behavior

Evaluating people’s spending behavior after receiving a stimulus check may be one of the important factors to determine how successful stimulus checks are–or aren’t. Understanding consumer response to receiving these payments can offer deeper insights into their overall economic impact.

Technological and Administrative Challenges

In 2020, older, outdated technology and a decrease in IRS personnel caused some delays in sending checks. For this program to work well, ensuring the money gets delivered quickly and safely to people should be a high priority.

How Do Stimulus Checks Differ from Tax Credits?

While the government may use both stimulus checks and tax credits support their taxpayers and stimulate the economy, they operate differently.

A tax credit is a reduction in the amount of taxes owed. It’s not a direct payment but rather an amount subtracted from the total tax liability, which can either reduce the amount of tax to be paid or increase a taxpayer’s refund after filing taxes.

Tax credits may target specific behaviors or circumstances, such as having children–child tax credits, for example–or making eco-friendly home improvements. While stimulus checks aim for a rapid effect on consumer spending, tax credits generally have a more delayed impact, since they’re usually handled when you file your taxes.

Case Studies: How Have Stimulus Checks Been Used in the Past?

Stimulus checks aren’t new. They’ve been used for crises, such as the Great Depression, when various forms of government assistance were introduced to stimulate the economy. However, the modern stimulus checks, especially in recent years, is more directly aimed at quick economic revival by putting money directly into the hands of consumers.

More recently, the stimulus checks issued during the 2008 financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic each had different impacts.

The Great Recession

In 2008, during the financial crisis, stimulus checks were issued to counter the severe economic downturn caused by the collapse of the housing market and the mortgage industry. These checks provided financial support to millions of Americans, boosting consumer spending at a time when the economy was in dire need. The extra cash helped to stabilize the economy by increasing demand for goods and services, which was essential for recovery.

The COVID-19 Pandemic

During the COVID-19 pandemic, stimulus checks played a different but equally vital role. With widespread job losses and business closures due to lockdowns, these checks offered immediate financial relief to individuals and families struggling with the sudden loss of income. The checks during the pandemic not only helped in managing basic needs but also in keeping the economy afloat by sustaining consumer spending in a time of unprecedented global economic shutdown. The COVID-19 stimulus checks were larger in amount and more frequent in distribution, which reflects just how much the economy was challenged during this time.

The Future of Stimulus Checks

Looking ahead, the role of stimulus checks in economic policy is subject to various factors. These include evolving economic conditions, political decisions, and the perceived effectiveness of past stimulus efforts. As governments and economists continue to evaluate the impacts of these payments, future strategies will likely be informed by lessons learned during previous economic crises.

Final Take: Balancing Immediate Relief with Long-Term Stability

Stimulus checks have proven their worth in providing quick economic relief, but their lasting effects are a subject of ongoing conversation. Consider the potential drawbacks, like increased national debt and inflation. Stimulus checks as a policy will be continually refined, guided by the current economy, government policy and how they’ve fared in helping the economy and the people in the past.

Editor's note: This article was produced via automated technology and then fine-tuned and verified for accuracy by a member of GOBankingRates' editorial team.

Share This Article: